Courses · LAW 301 Outside the Act · Lesson 1 of 4
Three questions, not one
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Which comes from the Indian Act?
- Can a person have descent without status?
- Being on a band’s list is…
Status is a Government of Canada registration under the Indian Act. Membership is being on a band’s list. Descent is who your ancestors were. They are three different questions with three different answers.
Many of the Loyalist Mohawk posterity have descent and no status or membership at all. The Nation holds that their interest rests on descent from the class, which neither of the others can give or take away.
Each of the three has its own keeper and its own proof. Status is kept by Canada, in the Indian Register that the Act has required since 1951, and it is proved by a certificate. Membership is kept by a band, under the Act or under the band’s own code, and it is proved by the band list. Descent is kept by no government; it is a fact, proved by records of birth, marriage and death, generation by generation.
They come apart all the time. A person can have status and belong to no band. A person can be a band member under a band’s code without status. And a great many people descend from the Mohawk of the three villages and have neither: their grandmothers married out, or their families left the reserve, or they were never on a list at all.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Status” means. Then read on.
The Nation’s position is that the interest under the Proclamation follows the third. The instruments speak of the Mohawk of named villages and their posterity. Posterity is a word of descent. It does not mean “those the Department has registered”, and it could not, since the Department’s register was not created until long after.
This has a hard edge as well as a generous one. Descent must be proved. A family tradition is where a search begins, never where it ends. The Register asks for a documented line to a person of the class, link by link, to the standard genealogists use, and it marks plainly any link that is not yet documented.
It follows that no one can be given the interest by enrolment, and no one can lose it by being struck off. That is the meaning of the course’s title. The class stands outside the Act: the Act neither created it nor can end it.
Try the three questions on a single family across four generations. You will usually find that the answers change from one generation to the next for status and membership, as marriages and amendments come and go, while the answer for descent never changes at all.
Key terms
- Status
- Registration under the Indian Act.
- Membership
- Being on a band’s list.
- Descent
- Who your ancestors were.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Status, Membership, Descent.