Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · ART 102 Making and keeping: studio, critique and collections · Lesson 4 of 4

A maker’s rights

Lecture 4 of 4 · about 8 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Does buying a painting buy its copyright?
  2. What did the court order in Snow’s case?
  3. Does copyright protect a design held by a community for generations?

The last lesson of ART 101 ended with a rule: makers have names. This lesson sets out what the law gives a maker, what it does not, and what a maker should do to protect their work.

In Canada the maker of an original work owns the copyright in it from the moment it is made. Nothing need be registered or marked. Copyright lasts for the maker’s life and seventy years. It gives the maker alone the right to copy the work, to publish it and to authorise others to do so. For works made since 1988 it includes the right to authorise, and so to be paid for, showing the work at a public exhibition that is not for sale or hire. Selling the object does not sell the copyright. Whoever buys a painting owns the canvas, and may not print it on shirts.

Beside these stand the maker’s moral rights, in the section printed below. There are two. The right of attribution is the right to be named as the maker, or to use another name, or to stay anonymous. The right of integrity is the right not to have the work distorted, mutilated or otherwise modified in a way that harms the maker’s honour or reputation. Moral rights cannot be sold. They can only be waived, and they are not waived merely because the copyright is sold.

The leading case is a memorable one. Michael Snow made Flight Stop, a flock of Canada geese in flight, for the Eaton Centre in Toronto. At Christmas 1981 the Centre tied red ribbons round their necks. Snow went to court, and in 1982 the judge held that the ribbons distorted his work to the harm of his reputation, and ordered them off. The Centre owned the geese. It did not own the right to alter them.

A maker protects these rights by simple habits. Sign and date the work. Keep a record of every piece: title, date, materials, size and a photograph. Put any commission, sale of rights or loan in writing, however friendly the arrangement, and say what may be done with the work and what may not. Ask for a credit line wherever the work is shown or printed. CARFAC, the association of Canada’s visual artists, publishes a schedule of minimum fees for showing and reproducing work, and a maker is entitled to quote it. PUB 101 gave the Nation’s own rule: a member’s work remains the member’s, and a work the Nation commissions follows the commission agreement.

The picture sets what copyright protects beside what it does not reach. Read down each column.
Copyright protectsA work by a named makerFrom the moment it is madeFor life and seventy yearsThe right to copy, show and be namedIt does not reachA design held by a communityA style or a techniqueAnything older than the termKnowledge handed down without one author

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Copyright” means. Then read on.

Now the limits, which matter greatly here. Copyright protects a work by an author for a term. It does not protect a style or a technique. It does not protect a design that has been in a community for generations: such a design has no single author, and is older than any term. Nor does it stop anyone from selling goods made “in the style of” a people. The United States has had a law since 1990 against selling as Indian-made what is not. Canada has no such statute, and relies on its ordinary law against misleading advertising.

The Declaration, in the article ART 101 printed, affirms a people’s right to control and protect its cultural heritage and traditional cultural expressions. Canadian law does not yet give that right effect, and negotiations on an international instrument have gone on at Geneva for more than twenty years. In the meantime protocol does what law does not. CARFAC’s Indigenous Protocols for the Visual Arts, written under the guidance of an Indigenous advisory circle, begins from the point that there are no universal rules, and that the people in authority in a particular nation or community are the ones to ask.

So a Mohawk maker stands in two systems at once. The law protects the piece you made, in your name, for your life and seventy years. Protocol protects what you drew on: the designs, the stories and the skills that were handed to you, and that are not yours alone to sell. A careful maker honours both, and says in the statement that goes with a work which parts are their own and which were given.

To finish the course, write the record for the piece you made in the first lesson: title, date, materials, size, a photograph, a credit line, and two sentences saying what you drew on and with whose leave. That record, kept with the work, is the beginning of its provenance. A museum a century from now will not have to write “maker unknown”.

The source

The author of a work has, subject to section 28.2, the right to the integrity of the work and, in connection with an act mentioned in section 3, the right, where reasonable in the circumstances, to be associated with the work as its author by name or under a pseudonym and the right to remain anonymous.
Copyright Act, section 14.1(1) · R.S.C. 1985, c. C-42.

Key terms

Copyright
The maker’s sole right to copy and publish a work, for life and seventy years.
Moral rights
The maker’s rights to be named and to keep the work from distortion.
Waiver
Giving up a right by agreement; moral rights can be waived and never sold.
Traditional cultural expression
A design, story, song or form held by a people and handed down.

Check yourself

1.Does buying a painting buy its copyright?
2.What did the court order in Snow’s case?
3.Does copyright protect a design held by a community for generations?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Copyright, Moral rights, Waiver, Traditional cultural expression.