Courses · ART 102 Making and keeping: studio, critique and collections · Lesson 3 of 4
Collections, museums and return
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 8 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What happened at the Onondaga longhouse on the Grand River in 1988?
- Does any federal law in Canada require a museum to return what it holds?
- Why is the maker so often “unknown” in old records?
Most of the old Mohawk and Six Nations work that survives is not in the hands of the families who made it. It is in museums, in Canada, the United States and Europe. This lesson teaches where to look, how to read what a museum says about a piece, and how some things have come home.
Some works never left. The communion silver that Queen Anne gave in 1712 is still held by the Mohawk, divided between the Chapel on the Grand River and the Bay of Quinte. The Woodland Cultural Centre at Brantford has kept a museum and collection since 1972. Other works are in public collections that anyone may visit or search online. Verelst’s four portraits of 1710 belong to Library and Archives Canada. Romney’s portrait of Joseph Brant hangs in the National Gallery of Canada. Beadwork, baskets, silver and carving are held by the Canadian Museum of History, the Royal Ontario Museum, the Smithsonian’s National Museum of the American Indian, the British Museum and many smaller places.
Every museum keeps a record for each thing it holds, and most now publish them. Learn its parts. The accession number says when the piece entered the collection and identifies it for ever. The record names the object, the maker, the people, the date, the materials and the size. Its provenance is the chain of hands the piece passed through, the same idea HIS 102 taught for documents. Read old records with care. The maker is very often “unknown”, and the people given only as “Iroquois”, because the collector did not ask. The date is often the date of collecting. And how the piece left its community may not be recorded at all.
Those gaps can sometimes be filled. Families recognise a grandmother’s hand in a pattern of beads. Researchers working with communities have put names back on work long labelled anonymous, and one alliance of scholars and community researchers, known as GRASAC, gathers records of Great Lakes pieces from museums across the world into one shared database. A museum will usually let a member of the community concerned see a piece in store, by appointment. Ask.
Some things were never meant to be collected. A wampum belt is a record, as ART 101 taught, and it belongs with those whose record it is. Eleven belts of the Confederacy disappeared from the Grand River after the death of their keeper in 1893 and were sold to a dealer a few years later. They passed to a collector in New York and into his museum. In 1988 that museum returned all eleven to the Confederacy at the Onondaga longhouse on the Grand River. In 1989 the New York State Museum returned twelve belts to the Onondaga Nation, and in 1991 Canada’s national museum returned three more to the Confederacy. This University teaches these returns as history. The belts are the Confederacy’s, and the Nation does not speak for it.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Accession number” means. Then read on.
The law on return differs sharply on the two sides of the border. In the United States an Act of 1990, known as NAGPRA, requires federal agencies and any museum receiving federal money to list what they hold and to return human remains, funerary objects, sacred objects and objects of cultural patrimony to the descendants and tribes they belong to. It serves tribes recognised by the United States. A nation in Canada has no claim under it as of right. In Canada no federal law requires a museum to return anything. Requests are decided case by case, under each museum’s own policy. Among the provinces, Alberta has a statute, passed in 2000, for sacred ceremonial objects.
What Canada has are reports and a Declaration. A task force of the Assembly of First Nations and the Canadian Museums Association reported in 1992 and asked museums to work with the peoples whose things they hold. In 2015 the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, in Call to Action 67, asked for a national review of museum practice against the Declaration. The Museums Association’s answer, Moved to Action, came in 2022 with ten recommendations, among them more money for Indigenous cultural centres, to support returns. The Declaration’s article is printed below. It asks states to seek to enable access and return, through mechanisms developed with the peoples concerned.
One class of thing needs separate mention. ART 101 explained that the medicine masks are sacred and are not to be exhibited or pictured. Museums that hold them have increasingly taken them off display, and some have returned them. This course does not show them, and the exercise below does not include them.
For this lesson, find one Mohawk or Six Nations work in a public collection’s online record. Copy out its accession number and what the record says of the maker, the date, the materials and how the museum came by it. List what the record does not say. Then write a courteous letter of one paragraph to the museum, asking one question that might fill a gap. Send it if you wish. Many museums have someone whose work it is to answer such letters.
The source
States shall seek to enable the access and/or repatriation of ceremonial objects and human remains in their possession through fair, transparent and effective mechanisms developed in conjunction with indigenous peoples concerned.United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, article 12(2) · UN General Assembly resolution 61/295, 13 September 2007.
Key terms
- Accession number
- The number a museum gives a piece when it enters the collection.
- Provenance
- The chain of hands through which a piece has passed.
- Repatriation
- The return of a thing to the people it came from.
- Cultural patrimony
- A thing that belongs to a people as a whole and that no one person could give away.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Accession number, Provenance, Repatriation, Cultural patrimony.