Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · ART 102 Making and keeping: studio, critique and collections · Lesson 2 of 4

Critique

Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What is the first of Feldman’s four steps?
  2. What did Pauline Johnson criticise in 1892?
  3. In Lerman’s process, what must a responder do before giving an opinion?

In May 1892 a newspaper in Toronto printed an essay by a writer from the Grand River, thirty-one years old, who was just beginning to be known. Pauline Johnson’s subject was the “Indian girl” of the novels of her day, and her opening is printed below. Her complaint was that novelists kept drawing one stock figure and giving her no nation of her own, where a writer who knew the people would have drawn a particular woman of a particular nation. It is criticism of a high order: exact about what is on the page, informed about what is missing from it, and clear in its judgment. It is also a Mohawk writer judging how her people were pictured, which ART 101 asked you to do.

Critique is the practice of looking hard at a work and saying something useful about it. It is a skill apart from making, and it is learned by a method. The best-known method comes from the American teacher Edmund Feldman, and has four steps, taken strictly in order.

Describe. Say what is there, as if to someone who cannot see it: the size, the materials, the shapes and colours, what is shown. No opinions yet. This is harder than it sounds, and most poor criticism fails here, by judging before it has looked.

Analyse. Say how the parts are arranged, in the words ART 101 gave you: line, shape, colour and value; balance, contrast, rhythm and emphasis. Where does the eye go first, and what sends it there?

Interpret. Say what you think the work means or does, and point to what in it makes you think so. An interpretation is a claim with evidence, like any other. Two people may reasonably differ, and each must be able to show where in the work their reading comes from.

The picture sets out the four steps of a critique. Read it from left to right; the cultural context is considered throughout.
DescribeWhat is there?AnalyseHow is it arranged?InterpretWhat does it mean,and what shows that?JudgeDoes it succeed, andat what?

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Critique” means. Then read on.

Judge. Say whether the work succeeds, and at what. Judge it against what it was trying to do, and against the best work of its kind, and give reasons.

Ontario’s curriculum adds a step that Feldman’s four leave out, and Johnson’s essay shows why it matters: consider the cultural context. Who made this, for whom, and by what protocol? What would a person of the maker’s own nation see in it that an outsider would miss? A critic who does not know should say so, and ask. Much of what was written about Mohawk work for two centuries was confident description by people who had not asked.

Critique in a group needs rules, because the maker is in the room. The choreographer Liz Lerman worked out a set in 1990 that many studios use. First, those responding say what was meaningful or striking to them in the work. Second, the maker asks the questions they want answered. Third, responders ask the maker neutral questions, with no opinion folded inside: “what guided your choice of colour?” and not “why is it so dark?” Fourth, a responder who has an opinion asks leave to give it, and the maker may say no.

When your own work is on the table, listen and take notes. Do not explain or defend: if the work needs you beside it to explain it, it is not finished. Afterwards, decide for yourself which remarks to act on. The work is yours.

For this lesson, write a critique of one page on a classmate’s piece from the studio assignment, in Feldman’s four steps with the fifth added, and take part in a group critique under Lerman’s rules. Then write three sentences on what you will change in your own work as a result.

The source

Every race in the world enjoys its own peculiar characteristics, but it scarcely follows that every individual of a nation must possess these prescribed singularities, or otherwise forfeit in the eyes of the world their nationality. Individual personality is one of the most charming things to be met with, either in a flesh and blood existence, or upon the pages of fiction, and it matters little to what race an author’s heroine belongs, if he makes her character distinct, unique and natural.
E. Pauline Johnson (Tekahionwake), “A Strong Race Opinion: On the Indian Girl in Modern Fiction”: the opening · Toronto Sunday Globe, 22 May 1892.

Key terms

Critique
A reasoned account of a work: what it is, how it is made, what it means and whether it succeeds.
Interpretation
A claim about what a work means, supported from the work.
Cultural context
Who made a work, for whom, and under what protocol.
Neutral question
A question to a maker with no opinion folded inside it.

Check yourself

1.What is the first of Feldman’s four steps?
2.What did Pauline Johnson criticise in 1892?
3.In Lerman’s process, what must a responder do before giving an opinion?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Critique, Interpretation, Cultural context, Neutral question.