Courses · LAW 102 Legal method: finding the law, reading a case, review and ethics · Lesson 4 of 4
Ethics and the moot
Lecture 4 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What must you do with a binding authority against you that the other side missed?
- How should you begin an oral argument?
- Why are you assigned a side in a moot?
A person who argues a case takes on duties. Lawyers are bound to them by their law societies. Anyone else who speaks in a court or writes to one, as officers of the Nation and its members do, is wise to keep the same rules, because judges expect them and because they are right.
The first duty is candour. You may not mislead a court, about the facts or the law. You may not put forward a document you know to be false, or cite a case for something it does not say. And there is a rule that surprises beginners: an advocate must tell the court of a binding authority directly against them if the other side has missed it. You then argue why it does not apply. A court that finds you hid a case will not believe the rest of what you say, in that case or the next.
The second is honesty about what you are. Do not call yourself a lawyer if you are not licensed as one. A person may speak for themselves in most courts, and the Supreme Court has endorsed principles asking judges to help self-represented people understand procedure. But speaking for others is regulated, and the rules differ by court. State plainly in what capacity you appear, and by what authority.
The third is competence: do the reading. Know your record, the rules of the court and the time limits. Missing a deadline loses more cases than weak argument does.
The fourth is confidentiality toward whoever you act for, and loyalty: you do not act where your own interest, or a duty to someone else, pulls the other way.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Candour” means. Then read on.
The fifth is civility. Address the bench properly. Never interrupt a judge. Do not attack your opponent personally. State the other side’s position fairly, as FAC 106 teaches, before answering it. Courtesy is what lets a hard point be heard, and a court will listen longer to someone who is courteous.
A sixth has become urgent. Whatever tool helps you draft, you answer for every word and every citation. Courts in New York and British Columbia have penalised people who filed cases an artificial-intelligence tool invented.
These duties are practised in a moot: an argument on a set problem before a bench, with a side assigned to you. Prepare in four steps. Read the problem until you could state the facts without notes. Write the issues as questions. Find and brief the authorities on both sides. Then write a short written argument: for each issue, your position, the rule with its authority, its application, and the order you ask for.
In oral argument, begin by telling the bench in two sentences what you ask for and why. Give your best point first. Expect questions and welcome them: a question shows you what troubles the judge. Answer it directly, at once, and then return to your plan. If you do not know, say so. Concede what you must, and stop when you have finished.
You will often be assigned the side you think is wrong. That is the point of the exercise. The article printed below promises everyone a fair hearing, and a hearing is fair only if each side is argued as well as it can be.
The source
Everyone is entitled in full equality to a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal, in the determination of his rights and obligations and of any criminal charge against him.Universal Declaration of Human Rights, article 10 · UN General Assembly resolution 217 A (III), 10 December 1948.
Key terms
- Candour
- The duty not to mislead a court, including disclosing binding authority against you.
- Self-represented
- Appearing in court for oneself, without a lawyer.
- Moot
- A practice argument on a set problem before a bench.
- Written argument
- The document setting out a party’s position, authorities and the order sought; in Canada often called a factum.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Candour, Self-represented, Moot, Written argument.