Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · LAW 102 Legal method: finding the law, reading a case, review and ethics · Lesson 2 of 4

Reading and citing a case

Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Which part of a judgment binds later courts?
  2. What are the five heads of a brief?
  3. What is 2004 SCC 25?

A judgment is a court’s written reasons for deciding a dispute. Lawyers read judgments for one thing above all: the rule the court applied, which later courts will follow. Finding that rule in forty pages takes a method.

A judgment has regular parts. The style of cause names the parties, as in Isaac v. Davey. The court and the date tell you how much weight it carries: a decision of the Supreme Court of Canada binds every court in the country, a Court of Appeal binds the courts of its province, and a trial decision persuades without binding. The facts are what happened, as the court found them. The issue is the legal question to be answered. The reasons work through the law. The disposition says who won and what was ordered. There may also be a dissent, in which a judge who disagreed explains why. A dissent is not law, though today’s dissent is sometimes tomorrow’s rule.

Inside the reasons, separate two things. The ratio decidendi is the rule that was necessary to decide the case on its facts. It is what binds. Obiter dicta are things said in passing that the decision did not depend on. They may be persuasive, and they do not bind. Much legal argument is about which is which.

The tool for getting a case under control is the brief: a one-page summary under five heads. Facts: only those that mattered to the result. Issue: the question, put so that it can be answered yes or no. Rule: the law the court stated. Analysis: how the court applied the rule to the facts. Conclusion: the answer and the order. Writing the brief forces you to decide what the case stands for, in your own words, before you rely on it.

Take care to state what a case decided and nothing more. Isaac v. Davey, in 1977, is often cited for more than it holds. Brief it yourself, and note what the Court said it was deciding and what it said it was leaving alone.

The picture shows the five heads of a case brief. Read it from left to right.
FactsOnly those thatmatteredIssueA question with ayes or no answerRuleThe law the courtstatedAnalysis andconclusionHow it applied; whowon; the order

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Ratio decidendi” means. Then read on.

Cite cases as Canadian lawyers do, following the Canadian Guide to Uniform Legal Citation, known as the McGill Guide. Since about 2000, courts have given each decision a neutral citation: the year, the court and a number, as in Garland v. Consumers’ Gas Co., 2004 SCC 25. Older cases are cited to a printed reporter: Isaac v. Davey, [1977] 2 S.C.R. 897. Point to the exact place with a paragraph number where the judgment has them, and a page where it does not.

Statutes are cited by title, the volume in which they are printed, the chapter and the section. The provision printed below would be cited as the Constitution Act, 1867 (UK), 30 & 31 Vict, c 3, s 109. Quote a provision exactly, and never paraphrase it inside quotation marks.

Then put the pieces together as lawyers do, in four steps: the issue, the rule with its authority, the application of the rule to your facts, and the conclusion. Every paragraph of a legal argument has that shape.

When you cite a case against yourself, as you must where it binds, brief it with the same care. You cannot distinguish a case you have not understood.

The source

All Lands, Mines, Minerals, and Royalties belonging to the several Provinces of Canada, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick at the Union […] shall belong to the several Provinces of Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick in which the same are situate or arise, subject to any Trusts existing in respect thereof, and to any Interest other than that of the Province in the same.
Constitution Act, 1867, section 109: a provision to cite · 30 & 31 Vict., c. 3 (UK).

Key terms

Ratio decidendi
The rule necessary to decide a case; the part that binds.
Obiter dicta
Things said in passing in a judgment, which do not bind.
Brief
A one-page summary of a case: facts, issue, rule, analysis, conclusion.
Neutral citation
A court’s own reference for a decision: year, court and number.

Check yourself

1.Which part of a judgment binds later courts?
2.What are the five heads of a brief?
3.What is 2004 SCC 25?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Ratio decidendi, Obiter dicta, Brief, Neutral citation.