Courses · LAW 102 Legal method: finding the law, reading a case, review and ethics · Lesson 3 of 4
Judicial review and mandamus
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What does mandamus do?
- What must an applicant have done before seeking it?
- On reasonableness review, what does the court ask?
Most law that touches a person’s life is applied by officials and not by judges: a registrar, a minister, a licensing office, a tribunal. Administrative law is the body of rules that governs them, and judicial review is the means by which a court checks that they have kept within the law. Anyone who deals with governments on the Tract needs to understand it.
Two ideas run through the subject. An official has only the power the law gives, and must use it for the purpose it was given. And a person affected by a decision is owed fairness in how it is made.
A court reviewing a decision asks about three things. Jurisdiction: did the decision-maker have power to decide this at all? Procedure: was the person told the case against them and given a chance to answer, by someone impartial? The Supreme Court set out what fairness requires in Baker in 1999, and it varies with how much is at stake. Substance: is the decision one the law allows? Since Vavilov in 2019 the usual test is reasonableness. The court does not ask what it would have decided. It asks whether the decision is justified by reasons that are transparent and intelligible, in light of the facts and the law that bound the decision-maker.
The remedies have old names. Certiorari quashes a decision. Prohibition stops a body from acting outside its power. A declaration states what the law is. And mandamus, the Latin for “we command”, orders an official to perform a duty the law imposes. The Federal Court’s power to grant them against federal bodies is in the section printed below; the superior courts of the provinces have the same power over provincial ones.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Judicial review” means. Then read on.
Mandamus is the remedy for silence and delay, and it has a strict test, set out by the Federal Court of Appeal in Apotex in 1993 and followed since. There must be a public legal duty to act. The duty must be owed to the applicant. There must be a clear right to its performance: the applicant has met every condition the law sets, has made a prior demand that the duty be performed, has allowed a reasonable time, and has been refused, either outright or by unreasonable delay. No other adequate remedy may be available. The order must have some practical value. And nothing in fairness must stand in the way, on a balance of convenience.
Notice two limits. Mandamus compels an official to decide or to act. It does not usually tell them which way to decide where the law leaves a choice. And it lies only for a duty, something the law says must be done. A power that may be used is not enough.
Read the test again with the Nation’s practice in mind. A letter that states the duty, cites the instrument that imposes it, asks for one thing and names a date is a prior demand. Proof of service shows it was received. A Declaration of Non-Response records that a reasonable time passed without an answer. The diplomatic record taught in DIP 201 is built, step for step, to supply what the third part of the test asks for.
Whether a particular duty exists is always the hard question, and it is contested. The Nation holds, for example, that the ascertainment on oath provided for in 1796 was never carried out for the Mohawk class. Whether a court would find a duty there that it could compel is a matter of argument on the instruments. A student should be able to set out both sides.
The source
Subject to section 28, the Federal Court has exclusive original jurisdiction (a) to issue an injunction, writ of certiorari, writ of prohibition, writ of mandamus or writ of quo warranto, or grant declaratory relief, against any federal board, commission or other tribunal.Federal Courts Act, section 18(1)(a) · R.S.C. 1985, c. F-7.
Key terms
- Judicial review
- A court’s check that an official or tribunal has kept within the law.
- Procedural fairness
- The right to know the case and answer it before an impartial decision-maker.
- Reasonableness
- The usual standard of review: a decision justified by transparent and intelligible reasons.
- Mandamus
- A court’s order that an official perform a public legal duty.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Judicial review, Procedural fairness, Reasonableness, Mandamus.