Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · FAC 103 Assessing learning and academic integrity · Lesson 3 of 4

Feedback

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Which of the three questions does a bare mark answer?
  2. What should feedback comment on?
  3. How do you mark a position you disagree with?

A mark tells a learner where they stand. Feedback tells them how to move. Of the two, feedback matters more, and it is the part most often done badly or late.

In 2007 two researchers in New Zealand, John Hattie and Helen Timperley, reduced a large body of evidence to three questions that good feedback answers. Where am I going? That is the standard, and the rubric gives it. How am I doing? That is where this piece of work stands against the standard. Where to next? That is the one thing that would most improve it. Feedback that answers only the second question, as a bare mark does, leaves the learner knowing they fell short and not knowing what to do.

Five habits make feedback usable. Be prompt: comments returned after the next task is handed in are read by nobody. A week is a fair limit for most work. Be specific: point to a sentence, a citation, a step in the argument. Be selective: two or three things a learner can act on are worth more than twenty marks in the margin. Say what is good, exactly, so that they do it again. And comment on the work and never on the person: “this paragraph asserts and does not show” can be used, and “you are careless” cannot.

Give the learner something to do with it. The surest way is to let work be revised. If that is impossible, ask the learner to write two lines at the top of their next piece saying what they changed because of your last comments. Feedback that is not used has not happened.

Three cards, one for each question good feedback answers. Read each from the top: the question, what supplies the answer, and an example.
Where am I going?The standard, from therubric.“A thesis supported from thesources”How am I doing?This piece against thestandard.“Your thesis is clear; twoclaims have no source”Where to next?The one change that wouldhelp most.“Tie each claim to a passage”

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Feedback” means. Then read on.

Feedback on a position you disagree with needs particular care, and in this University you will meet it. A learner argues that a Crown instrument means something other than what the Nation holds, or other than what you hold. Mark the argument. Ask where the source supports the claim. Point to the strongest objection and ask how they would answer it. Do the same, with the same rigour, for a learner who agrees with you. If your comments are harder on one conclusion than on the other, you are marking opinions.

Some feedback is for the whole class. When the same weakness appears in many pieces, do not write it thirty times. Teach it again, differently, and say that you are doing so because the first attempt, yours, did not work.

Ask for feedback yourself. Three questions on a card half-way through a course will do: what is helping you learn, what is getting in the way, and what one thing should change? Read the cards, tell the class what you learned from them, and change something. Adults notice whether a teacher who gives feedback can also take it.

The purpose of all of it is in the sentence printed below, from the Universal Declaration: the development of the person. A comment is worth writing only if it serves that.

The source

Education shall be directed to the full development of the human personality and to the strengthening of respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms.
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, article 26(2) · UN General Assembly resolution 217 A (III), 10 December 1948.

Key terms

Feedback
Information that tells a learner where they stand against the standard and what to do next.
Feed forward
The part of feedback that says what to do next.
Revision
Reworking a piece in the light of comments.

Check yourself

1.Which of the three questions does a bare mark answer?
2.What should feedback comment on?
3.How do you mark a position you disagree with?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Feedback, Feed forward, Revision.