Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · FAC 103 Assessing learning and academic integrity · Lesson 1 of 4

For learning and of learning

Lecture 1 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What is a lesson’s self-check?
  2. Why keep stakes low while people are learning?
  3. What makes a judgment reliable?

What you will be able to do

  • Tell for, as and of learning apart.
  • Check often and cheaply.
  • Keep summative tasks valid, reliable and fair.

Unit 13 of 20 · the plan

  1. Before the session1½ h
  2. The lesson1½ h
  3. The case½ h
  4. The seminar1½ h
  5. The check¼ h
  6. Hand in¾ h

About6 hours

Assessment does two different jobs, and trouble comes from confusing them. Assessment of learning is a judgment at the end: has this person reached the outcome? Teachers call it summative. Assessment for learning happens along the way, and its purpose is to tell the learner and the teacher what to do next. Teachers call it formative. The first is a verdict. The second is information.

The case for the second was made in 1998 by two English researchers, Paul Black and Dylan Wiliam, who reviewed some 250 studies and found that frequent, low-stakes checking with useful feedback raised achievement more than almost anything else a teacher could do, and helped the weakest learners most. Ontario’s assessment policy for schools, Growing Success (2010), is built on the same finding. It adds a third kind, assessment as learning, in which learners judge their own work against the standard and decide for themselves what to do about it.

This University uses all three, and you should know which is which. The self-check at the foot of every lesson is assessment for learning. It can be taken any number of times. A reason is given for every answer, right or wrong, because the reason is where the learning is. The three questions at the top of each lesson, tried before reading, are assessment as learning: the learner finds out what they do not yet know. The practice exam for a certificate, described in the passage below, sits between. The final task, marked with a rubric, is assessment of learning.

Three rules follow for the instructor. Check often and cheaply. A two-minute question in the middle of a class tells you more than a test a month later, when it is too late to do anything. Keep the stakes low while people are learning. If every attempt counts toward the mark, learners hide what they do not understand, which is the very thing you need to see. And act on what you find. A check that changes nothing in the next class was a waste of everyone’s time.

The picture compares the two jobs of assessment. Read down each column; the last line of each gives an example from this University.
Assessment for learningAlong the wayTells learner and teacher what to do nextLow stakes; may be repeatedExample: the self-checkAssessment of learningAt the endJudges whether the outcome is reachedCounts; must be valid, reliable and fairExample: the final essay

A summative judgment has rules of its own. It must be valid: it must test the outcome and not something else, such as speed of handwriting or command of English where neither is the outcome. It must be reliable: two markers should reach about the same result, and the same marker the same result on Tuesday as on Friday. And it must be fair: every learner has had the chance to practise what is being judged. A rubric, the subject of the next lesson, serves all three.

Be sparing with summative tasks. One good final task that shows the main outcomes is better than five small ones that each show a fragment. The University’s scheme gives nearly half the mark to a final essay or brief for that reason.

Tell learners which kind each task is. An adult who knows that a self-check costs nothing will use it honestly. An adult who suspects that everything is being counted will treat every question as a trap.

The source

Twelve questions drawn from the courses, new each time. The pass mark is 80 per cent. Take it as often as you like.
The practice exam of a certificate programme · As printed on the programme pages of Mohawk University.

This lesson as a unit

Before the session1½ hours

Read. Black and Wiliam, “Inside the Black Box”; Growing Success.

Bring 150 words. Which kind is each task?

The case: The course file½ hour

The course file. A made-up instructor’s first module of four lessons, followed from orientation through design, assessment and access. Label every task in the module by its kind; add one two-minute check to each lesson.

The seminar1½ hours, live

The room sorts a course’s tasks by kind.

Path A · starting outThe tasks, half labelled.
Path B · officers and professionalsWrite the assessment plan.

Hand in: casebook entry 13 · For and of learning45 minutes

The assessment plan. Marked to a published guide, with written feedback in three parts: what the evidence supports, what is still assumed, and what to do next.

Key terms

Formative assessment
Assessment for learning: checks along the way that say what to do next.
Summative assessment
Assessment of learning: the judgment at the end.
Validity
A test’s measuring the outcome and not something else.
Reliability
Two markers, or one marker twice, reaching about the same result.

The questions of this lesson

  1. Choose oneWhat is a lesson’s self-check?
    1. A punishment
    2. Assessment for learning
    3. A final verdict
  2. Choose oneWhy keep stakes low while people are learning?
    1. Because marks are unimportant
    2. So they do not hide what they do not understand
    3. To save paper
  3. Choose oneWhat makes a judgment reliable?
    1. Two markers reaching about the same result
    2. A strict teacher
    3. A long test

They are answered and marked in My Register, where this sample lesson is open to every member: there it asks 6 questions in all, in four ways, with how sure you are and what is still unclear. No answers are published on this site.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Formative assessment, Summative assessment, Validity, Reliability.

Sample questions of the test →

This was the sample lesson

Assessing learning and academic integrity has three more lessons, each with its reading, its terms and its self-check, and a test drawn from the whole course. They are for enrolled learners, in My Register.

The first lesson is open to everyone. The full course is $60, and free for members of the Nation. What it costs