Courses · FAC 103 Assessing learning and academic integrity · Lesson 2 of 4
Rubrics
Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Which level should you write first?
- In marking a contested question, what earns the mark?
- What is moderation?
A rubric is a table that says, before the work is done, what will be looked for and what each level of quality looks like. It makes marking fairer, faster and easier to explain. It also teaches: a learner who has read the rubric knows what good work is.
There are two kinds. An analytic rubric sets out several criteria, each marked separately. A holistic rubric gives a single overall level with one description for each. Holistic marking is quick and suits short pieces. For a final essay or brief use an analytic rubric, because it shows a learner where they are strong and where they are weak.
Begin with the criteria. Take them from the outcomes: if an outcome says “argue a position from the sources”, argument and use of sources are criteria. Four or five are enough. Do not mark what is not an outcome. Neat handwriting, length and agreement with the instructor are not criteria in any course of this University.
Then write the levels. Four is the usual number, and Ontario’s schools use four in their achievement chart, where level three is the provincial standard. Write level three first. It describes work that fully meets the outcome, and it is the level you will have to defend most often. Then write level four, which goes beyond it. Then level two, which approaches it, and level one, which falls well short. Describe what the work does at each level. “Good use of sources” says nothing a learner can act on. “Every claim is tied to a passage in a source, and the passage is quoted or cited” does.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Analytic rubric” means. Then read on.
The University’s rubric for a final essay has four criteria: knowledge of the sources, argument and analysis, citation, and writing. The description of the standard for argument is printed below. Notice the last phrase. A learner at the standard has weighed the main reading against their own. That is how the University marks contested questions. The mark goes to the quality of the argument and the handling of the other side. It never goes to the conclusion reached. A learner who argues well against the Nation’s reading earns the same mark as one who argues equally well for it.
Give learners the rubric with the task, and spend ten minutes of a class marking a sample with it together. People are usually surprised by how much they agree once the criteria are in front of them.
Use the rubric to check yourself too. Before marking a set, mark three pieces with a colleague and compare. Where you differ by more than a level on a criterion, the description is unclear, and it is the description that should be fixed. This is called moderation. A set of marks that has been moderated can be relied on.
A rubric has limits. It cannot foresee everything, and now and then a piece of work is excellent in a way no criterion names. Say so in a comment, mark by the rubric, and improve the rubric for next time.
The source
States a clear thesis and supports it with evidence from the sources, weighing the main counter-reading.The University’s rubric for a final essay: the standard for “Argument and analysis” · As printed in each course’s Teacher’s guide.
Key terms
- Analytic rubric
- A rubric that marks each criterion separately.
- Holistic rubric
- A rubric that gives one overall level.
- Criterion
- One thing looked for in a piece of work, taken from an outcome.
- Moderation
- Markers comparing their marking of the same pieces to keep a common standard.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Analytic rubric, Holistic rubric, Criterion, Moderation.