Courses · DIP 201 The practice of diplomacy: writing, protocol and negotiation · Lesson 3 of 5
Negotiation
Lecture 3 of 5 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What is the difference between a position and an interest?
- What is a party’s real strength in a negotiation?
- What should you do with a proposal beyond your mandate?
Negotiation is listed in the Vienna Convention as one of the five functions of a mission, and it is the first workshop in the United Nations’ diploma for diplomats. It can be taught, and it rests on preparation far more than on cleverness at the table.
The modern method was set out in 1981 by Roger Fisher and William Ury of Harvard, and it has four rules. Separate the people from the problem: be easy on the person across the table and hard on the question. Focus on interests and not positions. A position is what a party says it wants; an interest is why it wants it, and two positions that cannot both be met often hide interests that can. Invent options before deciding, so that there is more than one way to agree. And insist on a standard that neither side made up: a law, a precedent, a market price, an expert’s measure.
To these add one idea the same authors named: your best alternative to a negotiated agreement. Before any talk, work out what you will do if there is no agreement. That alternative is your real strength. A party with a good one can wait, and a party with none will take what is offered. Work out the other side’s alternative as carefully as your own.
Preparation therefore means answering six questions in writing. What do we need, and why? What do they need, and why? What could each side give that costs it little and is worth much to the other? What standard can we both accept? What happens to each of us if we walk away? And who on their side can actually say yes?
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Position” means. Then read on.
At the table, the Mohawk council taught rules that negotiators have rediscovered. Hear the other side out completely before answering. Repeat back what was said, so that both know it was understood. Do not answer a serious proposal on the spot: withdraw, consider and reply the next day, point by point. Speak with one voice, and settle your own side’s differences in private first.
Negotiation among many parties adds its own craft. At a conference, text is built by consensus, and words not yet agreed sit in square brackets until they are. Much of the work is done in corridors. A small delegation succeeds by choosing one or two points that matter to it, finding others who share them, and trading support on everything else.
Three warnings. Never bargain against yourself by improving your offer before the other side has answered the last one. Never agree to a thing you lack the mandate to agree to: say you will refer it. And write down what was agreed before you part, in words both sides have read, because memories diverge within the day.
When an agreement is reached, the rule printed below takes over. It is the oldest rule of the law between nations, and its Latin name means that agreements are to be kept. Everything in this lesson is worth doing only because of it.
The source
Every treaty in force is binding upon the parties to it and must be performed by them in good faith.Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, 1969, article 26: pacta sunt servanda · Done at Vienna, 23 May 1969; 1155 U.N.T.S. 331.
Key terms
- Position
- What a party says it wants.
- Interest
- Why a party wants it; the need behind a position.
- Best alternative
- What a party will do if no agreement is reached; the source of its strength at the table.
- Consensus
- Agreement reached without a vote, when no party objects.
- Pacta sunt servanda
- Agreements are to be kept.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Position, Interest, Best alternative, Consensus, Pacta sunt servanda.