Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · CIV 101 The Nation’s institutions · Lesson 4 of 4

Votes and petitions

Lecture 4 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What is needed to change the foundational rules (as proposed)?
  2. May a member living abroad vote?
  3. How is secrecy kept?

The Nation’s offices are held by commission and appointment. Some decisions, though, belong to the members themselves: a change to the Nation’s foundational rules, and any question the Secretary-General puts to them. The book on elections sets out how those votes would be held. Its rules are proposed, for the Nation to adopt by its Gazette, and they are taught here as proposed.

Who may vote: a member of the class, ascertained on the Register and of full age; and a member by adoption, with the same standing as by descent. Where they live does not matter. The posterity is dispersed worldwide, and the vote follows the member, not the address. The roll of electors is drawn from the Register on the day the vote is called, and published with names only.

What it takes to carry: a change to the foundational rules needs two-thirds of those voting, with at least a third of the roll taking part. A question put by the Secretary-General needs a majority of those voting.

The book’s worked vote, with invented figures. Each row is a way of voting; the last is all together. Two-thirds is the mark to pass.
ChannelYesNoShare yesIn person2125878.5%By post963175.6%Online41810480.1%All channels72619379.0%: carried

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Roll of electors” means. Then read on.

The safeguards are five. One member, one vote: the ballot checks the elector against the roll, and a second ballot cancels the first if both arrive by different means. Secrecy: the ballot is separated from the elector’s name before it is counted. A count anyone can check: the tally is published by channel, and the ballots kept sealed for ninety days. Independence: the Returning Officer is appointed for the vote and has no interest in its outcome. Challenge: within fourteen days, to the Court of the Nation.

The book works a vote through, with invented figures. A roll of 2,140 electors; twenty-one days of voting, in person, by post or online; 919 ballots, 43 per cent of the roll, above the third required; 726 yes, 79 per cent, above two-thirds. Carried. A recount may be asked for where the margin is under two per cent, and is done by a second officer, in public.

Petitions are open to any resident. Any one resident’s petition is acknowledged within 14 days. At 25 signatures it receives a written answer, published. At 100 it is placed before the officers responsible, in public. At 250 the Secretary-General decides whether to put it to a vote. A signature counts once, and only from a member on the Register. The standards behind all of this are named: article 25 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the Venice Commission’s Code of Good Practice in Electoral Matters, and the Council of Europe’s recommendation on e-voting, which requires online voting to be secret, verifiable and auditable, with a paper or postal route always open.

Key terms

Roll of electors
Who may vote, drawn from the Register on the day a vote is called.
Returning Officer
The officer appointed to run a vote, with no interest in its outcome.
Two-thirds
The share needed to change the foundational rules.
Petition
A request to the Nation that any resident may make.

Check yourself

1.What is needed to change the foundational rules (as proposed)?
2.May a member living abroad vote?
3.How is secrecy kept?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Roll of electors, Returning Officer, Two-thirds, Petition.