Courses · CIV 101 The Nation’s institutions · Lesson 3 of 4
Drafting and making an instrument
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Which word does the book prefer?
- Who reviews an instrument before it is made?
- What do recitals do?
An instrument has parts, and the book lists them in order. The title: what it is, in a few words. The Record Code, given when it is entered. The authority: the instrument under which it is made, cited by its Record Code. The recitals: “Whereas…”, the reasons, briefly; they explain, they do not command. The definitions: each word with a special meaning, defined once. The provisions: numbered, one idea to each, saying what must be done, by whom, by when. Consistency: how it accords with the Nation’s founding instruments. Supersession: what it replaces, if anything. Commencement: when it takes effect. And the signature: the maker’s name and office, with its Edge Mark when printed.
The drafting follows the plain-language standard, ISO 24495-1. Write “must”, not “shall”, because readers misread “shall”. Write “may”, not “is entitled to, at its discretion”. Use the Nation’s own terms for its own institutions, not another government’s terms where they carry that government’s assumptions. One provision, one idea. A defined word used the same way throughout. A cross-reference by Record Code, never “the instrument mentioned above”.
The book gives a pair to learn from. Good: “The Treasurer General must publish the proof of reserves every day.” Not like this: “It shall be the duty of the Treasurer General, as and when appropriate, to cause to be published such proof of reserves as may be required from time to time.” The first says who, what and when. The second leaves each open to argument.
Then the instrument’s life. A drafter drafts it, with its authority. The Attorney General reviews it: is it lawful, consistent and clear? The Secretary-General decides whether to make it, and signs. The Registrar General enters it: Record Code, date, index. And it is published; subscribers are told, and it is served where the law requires.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Recital” means. Then read on.
Each hand does one thing. The drafter cannot enter. The Registrar General does not decide what the law should be. The Attorney General’s review is on the record. An instrument that reaches the public has passed through four offices, and each has left its name.
The rule that governs all drafting is printed below, and it is worth pinning above a desk.
Try it. Take any rule you know, from a club, a school or a workplace, and redraft it in this form: who must do what, by when, in one sentence, with “must”. Most rules get shorter and clearer.
The source
Draft so that a resident who has never read a law can tell, from the instrument alone, what it requires of them.The drafter’s rule · The Gazette and Law-making, Book XI, “Drafting”.
Key terms
- Recital
- A “Whereas” that gives a reason; it explains, it does not command.
- Provision
- A numbered rule: one idea, saying who must do what, by when.
- Supersession
- What an instrument replaces, cited by Record Code.
- Commencement
- When an instrument takes effect.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Recital, Provision, Supersession, Commencement.