Courses · CIV 102 Taking part: elections, comparison, news and action · Lesson 3 of 4
Judging news and official statements
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What did the fact-checkers do that others did not?
- How should an official statement be treated?
- Which claims deserve extra care?
A citizen has to decide every day what to believe, about their own government and everyone else’s. The right in the article printed below, to seek and receive information, is of use only to someone who can tell good information from bad. This lesson teaches a method that takes about a minute.
Researchers at Stanford University watched how different groups of people judged unfamiliar websites. Historians and students read each page carefully, from top to bottom, and were often fooled by a professional appearance. Professional fact-checkers did something else. They left the page almost at once, opened new tabs, and searched for what others said about the source. The researchers called this lateral reading, and the fact-checkers were faster and far more often right.
The educator Mike Caulfield turned the finding into four moves, known by the initials SIFT. Stop: before you read, share or react, pause, and notice if the item has made you angry or delighted, since strong feeling is what misleading material aims at. Investigate the source: who is behind it, and what do others say of them? Thirty seconds of searching is usually enough. Find better coverage: has the claim been reported by sources you already have reason to trust, and do they agree? Trace it to the original: follow the quotation, the figure or the photograph back to where it first appeared, and see whether it says what you were told.
The fourth move is the one this University teaches in every course, under another name: go to the source. A news report about a court decision is checked by reading the decision. A claim about what a proclamation says is checked by reading the proclamation.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Lateral reading” means. Then read on.
Official statements deserve the same treatment as news, neither more trust nor less. When a government, a band office, a ministry or the Nation’s own Secretariat issues a statement, ask five things. What exactly is claimed? What is the evidence, and is it shown or only asserted? What is left out? Who benefits if you believe it? And has anyone with knowledge contradicted it? An office that publishes its sources and its record makes this easy. An office that does not is asking for trust in place of proof. When a statement rests on an expert’s word, CIV 103 teaches how to test the expert.
Learn to tell kinds of writing apart. News reports what happened. Analysis explains it. Opinion argues for a view. Advertising is paid for, and should be labelled. A press of record, which PUB 101 describes, has a further duty: to publish official notices exactly, and to correct errors where readers will see the correction.
Be as strict with what you agree with as with what you dislike. People check hostile claims and wave friendly ones through, and that is how honest people end up repeating falsehoods. A claim that flatters your own side should make you more careful.
Lastly, be content not to know. “I have not been able to check that” is an honourable sentence, and it is much better than passing something on in case it is true.
The source
Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.Universal Declaration of Human Rights, article 19 · UN General Assembly resolution 217 A (III), 10 December 1948.
Key terms
- Lateral reading
- Leaving a page to find out what others say about its source.
- SIFT
- Stop, investigate the source, find better coverage, trace to the original.
- Official statement
- A statement issued by a government or public body.
- Correction
- A published acknowledgment and repair of an error.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Lateral reading, SIFT, Official statement, Correction.