Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · CIV 102 Taking part: elections, comparison, news and action · Lesson 1 of 4

What makes an election fair

Lecture 1 of 4 · about 8 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What are the five words of the electoral code?
  2. What is the first question to ask of a nation’s election?
  3. When is a procedure fair?

CIV 101 taught how the Nation’s votes and petitions work. This lesson gives you the yardstick by which any election, anywhere, is judged, so that you can hold the Nation’s own to it.

The yardstick has two sources. The first is the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, whose article on elections is printed below. The second is a code of good practice adopted in 2002 by the Venice Commission, a body of constitutional lawyers that advises the Council of Europe and is consulted far beyond it. The Nation’s book on elections, Book XII, names both as its standards. The code gathers the standard under five words, with a sixth condition.

Universal: everyone who belongs has the right to vote and to stand. Limits must be few and stated in advance: an age, a tie to the community. For a nation the first question is the roll: who is on it, how they got there, and how a person left off can get on. A fair election on an unfair roll is not fair.

Equal: each voter has one vote, and each vote counts the same. Where there are districts, they are of similar size. Candidates have equal chances: the same rules, the same access to voters, and nobody campaigning with the office’s own resources.

Free: voters form their opinions freely and express them freely. That means free speech and a free press during the campaign, no pressure or inducement, and accurate information about how and where to vote.

Secret: nobody can find out how a person voted, and nobody is made to show. Secrecy protects the voter against pressure from an employer, a family or an official. In a small community, where everyone is known, it matters more and is harder.

Direct: the people themselves choose those who will hold office.

The table sets out the five principles with a question to ask of any election. Read across.
PrincipleAskUniversalWho is on the roll, and how does one get on?EqualDoes each vote count the same?FreeCan people speak, hear and choose withoutpressure?SecretCan anyone find out how a person voted?DirectDo the people themselves choose?And the safeguardsWho runs it, who watches, who hears an appeal?

The sixth condition is that elections are held at regular intervals, so that office is always held on a recent mandate.

The code adds that these principles are worth little without three safeguards. The election must be organised by an impartial body. It must be open to observers. And there must be an effective way to appeal to someone independent, quickly enough to matter.

Now apply it to the rules in Book XII, which are proposed, for the Nation to adopt by its Gazette. The roll is drawn from the Register on the day a vote is called and published with names only, and any elector has fourteen days to ask to be added or corrected. Members of full age vote wherever in the world they live. Each has one vote, and a second ballot cancels the first. The ballot is separated from the elector’s name before it is counted. The tally is published and the ballots are kept sealed for ninety days. A Returning Officer with no interest in the outcome runs the vote, and a challenge goes to the Court of the Nation within fourteen days. For each of the five words and the three safeguards, write what the rules provide and whether you think it meets the standard.

One difference deserves a paragraph of its own. The Covenant and the code look to those who govern being chosen at periodic elections. The Nation’s offices are held by commission and appointment under the Secretary-General, and Book XII keeps votes of the members for changes to the foundational rules, for questions put to them, and for any office the Gazette makes elective. The book asks the critic’s question itself: why should a nation of appointed offices hold votes at all? Its answer is that the offices serve the members, and that some decisions, the foundations above all, belong to them. A learner should be able to state that answer, and to state what the standard would ask in addition. Where you are unsure, that is a question for the Nation’s officers, and asking it is part of what a citizen is for.

Do the same for an election you know in Canada or elsewhere. No system meets every point perfectly, and learning to see where each falls short is the beginning of being able to improve one.

A last observation. The five words describe a procedure. A procedure is fair when people who lose under it accept the result, and they do that only if they could see that the rules were kept.

The source

To vote and to be elected at genuine periodic elections which shall be by universal and equal suffrage and shall be held by secret ballot, guaranteeing the free expression of the will of the electors.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, article 25(b) · UN General Assembly resolution 2200A (XXI), 16 December 1966.

Key terms

Universal suffrage
The right of everyone who belongs to vote and to stand.
Secret ballot
A vote cast so that nobody can find out how a person voted.
Electoral roll
The list of those entitled to vote.
Observer
A person allowed to watch an election and report on whether the rules were kept.

Check yourself

1.What are the five words of the electoral code?
2.What is the first question to ask of a nation’s election?
3.When is a procedure fair?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Universal suffrage, Secret ballot, Electoral roll, Observer.