Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · LIN 101 Proving your line · Lesson 4 of 4

The five elements, the oath and the entry

Lecture 4 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. How many elements must each generation meet?
  2. Who verifies a decision that a generation is proved?
  3. What happens to an uploaded GEDCOM file?

When you have gathered your line, the Registrar works each generation through the five elements of the Genealogical Proof Standard, and the Register will not let a generation be proved until all five are met.

First, a research log: every source searched, including those that held nothing. Second, a full citation for each item: who made it, what it is, when, where in it, and where it is kept. Third, each item classed: the source original, derivative or authored; the information primary, secondary or indeterminable; the evidence direct, indirect or negative. Fourth, any conflict between records resolved in writing. Fifth, a written conclusion in the form the evidence calls for: a proof statement, a proof summary, or, where the evidence is indirect or records conflict, a proof argument.

A decision that a generation is proved does not stand until a second officer has reviewed and verified it; the officer who decided cannot verify their own decision. Oral testimony is recorded as a source in its own right. DNA is used only with the written consent of the person tested.

The steps run in order. Ask: the sign-up form at the Register, names in their parts. Gather: your line, peg by peg, with each record and its source. Review: the Registrar checks each peg and says when the line is ready. Swear: before a justice of the peace, the oath Simcoe’s Proclamation set in 1796. Enter: the line is entered with its Record Code; your certificate follows, and your passport and card after it.

From asking to the entry, in five steps. Beneath each is who acts.
AskThe sign-upform; names inpartsGatherThe line, pegby peg, withsourcesReviewThe Registrar;a secondofficerverifiesSwearBefore ajustice of thepeaceEnterA Record Code;then thecertificate

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Research log” means. Then read on.

The justice of the peace sees the line with each record, the Registrar’s review, your identity, and the form of the oath. The review means the justice need not be a genealogist: the oath is to something already checked.

If you already keep a family tree in a program, you need not type it again. Export it as a GEDCOM file and upload it at the Register. The file is read once, then deleted; only the line you choose is kept, and living relatives on it only with their consent. Citations in your tree come in as leads, to be checked against the records. A tree is not proof.

The book’s worked example follows an invented member through six generations. One generation has no baptism. It is bridged by the 1851 census and a marriage of 1864 that agree on the name, the age and the mother. The book’s advice: write the gap down as a gap. A line that shows where it is weak, and why it holds anyway, is more convincing than one that hides it.

The source

I, First Middle LAST, of Grand River Territory, do swear that I am descended, by either sex, from [the Loyalist ancestor], of the village of [Canajoharie, Tikondarago or Aughgugo], who adhered to the Unity of the Empire and joined the Royal Standard before the Treaty of Separation of 1783; and that the record of my descent now laid before you is true. So help me God.
The oath before the magistrate (specimen; proposed) · Honours, Heraldry and Ceremony, Book VI, “The mark of honour, confirmed”.

Key terms

Research log
Every source searched, including those that held nothing.
Proof argument
A written case for a conclusion from indirect or conflicting evidence.
GEDCOM
The standard file format for family trees.
Justice of the peace
The magistrate before whom the line is sworn.

Check yourself

1.How many elements must each generation meet?
2.Who verifies a decision that a generation is proved?
3.What happens to an uploaded GEDCOM file?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Research log, Proof argument, GEDCOM, Justice of the peace.