Courses · LIN 101 Proving your line · Lesson 3 of 4
Pegs, gaps and the standard of proof
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What standard does the Register apply to a link?
- What does a DNA ethnicity estimate prove about the three villages?
- What do paylists and band lists show?
Each link in the line, a peg, is a parent and a child. A peg is proved when a record made at the time names both: a baptism that names the parents, a marriage that names the bride’s father, a census that lists a household with ages and relationships, a death registration that names the parents. One good record for each peg is the aim; two that agree are better.
Each kind of record has its weakness, and the book lists them. Birth registrations may be late, with names misspelt. A baptism may be months or years after the birth. Marriages before 1869 do not always give parents. Census ages are rounded and relationships guessed. Paylists and band lists show status, not descent: read them for names and families. The informant on a death registration may be mistaken.
Old records are lost to fire and flood, were never kept, or were kept for settlers and not for the Mohawk. A gap is not the end of a line. The Register applies the ordinary civil standard: a link is proved when, on all the evidence, it is more likely than not. What bridges a gap is converging evidence, several records around the gap that point the same way.
The standard is the court’s own. In F.H. v. McDougall, 2008 SCC 53, the Supreme Court held there is one civil standard, the balance of probabilities. Oral history is evidence when it is useful and reasonably reliable: Mitchell v. M.N.R., 2001 SCC 33. The Register asks no more of a line than a court would, and no less.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Balance of probabilities” means. Then read on.
Evidence is weighed in order. Records on either side of the gap are strongest. Family papers made at the time are good. Oral history in the family is admissible, weighed for how it came down, from whom, and whether records support it. Naming patterns and godparents support, and are never enough alone. DNA matches with proved relatives support only.
Two cases need their own note. Lines through women: before 1869 a woman’s marriage often appears only under her husband’s name. Look for her baptism, her children’s baptisms, where godparents are often her own family, her parents’ wills, and the household she lived in before marriage. And adoption: a person received by the Nation’s law of adoption is within the class, and the line then runs from the adopting family.
Whatever the evidence, keep it honest: record what you looked for and did not find, as well as what you found.
The source
A surname alone proves nothing: many families share one. A DNA ethnicity estimate proves nothing about the three villages. DNA matches with known relatives can support a line, never replace the records.What proves nothing · Proving Your Line, Book XXXVII, “Trace down, generation by generation”.
Key terms
- Balance of probabilities
- More likely than not: the civil standard of proof.
- Converging evidence
- Several records round a gap that point the same way.
- Oral history
- What a family or community has handed down; evidence, weighed with the rest.
- Godparents
- Often a mother’s own family; a lead, never proof alone.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Balance of probabilities, Converging evidence, Oral history, Godparents.