Courses · DIP 102 Mohawk diplomacy: council, chain and Crown · Lesson 5 of 5
Before the world
Lecture 5 of 5 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Why did the appeal at Geneva never reach the floor?
- Who may be a party before the International Court of Justice?
- What outlasts every refusal?
When the Crown’s offices in Canada stopped answering, the people of the Grand River did what Brant had done. They went over the heads of the local officials, first to London and then to the world. This lesson follows those attempts, and what each teaches about choosing a forum.
In 1921 Deskaheh, a Cayuga chief and the speaker of the Six Nations council of that day, travelled to London to petition the King, and was referred back to Canada. In 1923 he went to Geneva, to the League of Nations, travelling on a passport issued at the Grand River. He stayed more than a year. The Netherlands transmitted the appeal, and Ireland, Panama, Persia and Estonia asked that it be heard. Britain objected that the matter was internal to its empire, and the appeal never reached the floor. In the autumn of 1924 Canada replaced the council at the Grand River with an elected one under the Indian Act. Deskaheh’s mission is part of the Grand River’s diplomatic history. The Nation notes it as such, and speaks only for itself.
One exchange from those years is worth study. On 6 March 1922, in the House of Commons at Westminster, the Colonial Secretary was asked when and by whom the Haldimand Treaty had been denounced. The Secretary was Winston Churchill. He named no date, no party and no instrument. His answer was that it was a matter for Canada. A question that cannot be answered on its merits is passed to another office, and the Nation’s record calls that pattern redirection.
The Mohawk Nation of Grand River took up its own case in the 1960s. As the Nation records it, Secretary-General Melvin Hill, with Dr Omar Z. Ghobashy, a lawyer of New York, formally presented the Mohawk case in 1963 and 1964, and in 1966 and 1967 took it to the International Court of Justice at The Hague, where it was blocked by a telegram from the Six Nations Confederacy. There is a point of law here that every student should know. Under article 34 of the Court’s Statute, only states may be parties in cases before the Court. A nation that is not a recognised state needs a state to bring its case, or a different forum.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “League of Nations” means. Then read on.
In 1995 a memorandum agreement was made between the Six Nations Council and the Mohawk people, as two parties, toward bringing claims arising from the residential schools before the World Court. The international case did not go ahead. The Nation records that the agreement treated the Mohawk as a party in their own right.
Since 2014 the Nation has worked mainly by written record. It has sent directives copied to the Governor General and the Lieutenant Governor, questions to ministers, and notices to municipalities. On 1 April 2026 it served a Representation and Notice on His Majesty the King, published it the same day in the press of record, and holds the receipt stamped at Buckingham Palace on 15 April. Where questions went unanswered past their time, it has recorded that too.
What does the century teach? A petition to a body that your opponent can keep you out of will fail on procedure, whatever its merits. A court that hears only states will not hear a nation without one. Unity matters: a case can be stopped from behind as well as from in front. And the record outlasts every refusal. Each attempt left papers that the next could build on, which is why the Nation now keeps its own.
The source
In the UK Parliament, asked when and by whom the Haldimand Treaty had been denounced, Winston Churchill names no date, party or instrument — “entirely a matter for the Government and Parliament of Canada”.The Colonial Secretary in the House of Commons, 6 March 1922, as Recognition and Relations records it · Recognition and Relations, Book V of the National Books (first edition, October 2026), section 2.
Key terms
- League of Nations
- The body of states founded in 1920 at Geneva; forerunner of the United Nations.
- International Court of Justice
- The United Nations’ court at The Hague; only states may be parties to its cases.
- Redirection
- Passing a question to another office instead of answering it.
- Forum
- The body before which a case is brought.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: League of Nations, International Court of Justice, Redirection, Forum.