Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · DIP 102 Mohawk diplomacy: council, chain and Crown · Lesson 4 of 5

The Crown among the Mohawk

Lecture 4 of 5 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What does a sovereign’s gift say?
  2. What kind of adoption was Prince Arthur’s in 1869?
  3. What does a visit or a gift do for an instrument?

Diplomacy is carried in more than letters. Between the Crown and the Mohawk it has been carried for three centuries in gifts, visits, adoptions and names, and each is an act on the record as surely as a treaty is. This lesson reads those acts as a diplomat would. It follows the Nation’s own account in Recognition and Relations.

Begin with gifts. Queen Anne’s Bible and communion silver of 1712 were given for the chapel of the Mohawk and were carried by the Loyalist Mohawk into exile; after the war the silver was divided between the Grand River and the Bay of Quinte. A sovereign’s gift names its recipient. It says who the giver believes the other to be.

Then visits. In 1860 the Prince of Wales came to the Grand River and signed the Queen Anne Bible in the Mohawk Chapel. In 1869 came Prince Arthur. Later came the future George V, and Queen Elizabeth II five times between 1951 and 2010. In the language of the first course, these are the sovereign coming in person to the place of the covenant.

Then adoption. In 1869 the Mohawk made Prince Arthur a chief. The Nation follows Pauline Johnson’s account, whose father conducted the ceremony. The prince was received into the Turtle clan and given a name, and a string was added to the circle of wampum to mark his place. In 1913, as Governor General of Canada, he sat in council with his brother chiefs. The Nation’s law distinguishes two things here and keeps them apart. Customary adoption receives a person into a named clan with full standing. An honorary name is a mark of respect and no more. Prince Arthur’s was the first kind.

The table sorts the Crown’s acts among the Mohawk into four kinds. Read across: the kind of act, an example with its date, and what it shows.
Kind of actAn exampleWhat it showsGiftThe Bible and silver, 1712Who the giver takes the otherto beVisitThe Queen at the Chapel, 1984The sovereign comes to thepartnerAdoptionPrince Arthur, 1869The relationship made personalWord in councilLord Dufferin, 1874A pledge spoken on the record

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Customary adoption” means. Then read on.

The Nation draws a conclusion from this, and you should weigh it. The Crown’s princes and its sitting Governor General received titles under the Mohawk’s customary law and sat in its council. The Crown cannot have joined that order in person, generation after generation, and now treat it as having no standing. This is also the reason the Nation gives for dealing with the Crown directly: the relationship was made personal, with the King’s own house.

Then words given in council. In 1874 the Governor General, Lord Dufferin, spoke at the Grand River, and the sentence recorded from that day is printed below. In 1904 King Edward VII, the prince who had signed the Bible, named the Mohawk Chapel a Chapel Royal. In 1984 Queen Elizabeth II unveiled there a plaque that names the Loyalist Mohawk in three languages. In 2010 she gave the handbells.

How should such acts be read? A critic may say they are ceremony and nothing follows from them in law. The reply is that diplomacy has always been conducted this way, in Egypt, in Byzantium and at Albany, and that states are held to their conduct as well as to their signatures. The Crown’s conduct is its own evidence of how it understood the relationship. And a visit, a gift or a name does not replace an instrument. It shows that the instrument was meant.

The source

Never shall the word of Britain once pledged be broken.
Lord Dufferin, Governor General, at the Grand River, 1874 · As recorded in Jasper T. Gilkison’s Narrative, and in Recognition and Relations, Book V of the National Books (first edition, October 2026), section 3.

Key terms

Customary adoption
Reception into a named clan, with full standing, under the Nation’s own law.
Honorary name
A name given as a mark of respect, without a clan.
Chapel Royal
A chapel belonging to the sovereign; the Mohawk Chapel has been one since 1904.
Conduct
What a party does, as evidence of how it understands a relationship.

Check yourself

1.What does a sovereign’s gift say?
2.What kind of adoption was Prince Arthur’s in 1869?
3.What does a visit or a gift do for an instrument?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Customary adoption, Honorary name, Chapel Royal, Conduct.