Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · FAC 105 The ethical use of AI in teaching and research · Lesson 3 of 4

A course policy

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What four things must a policy say?
  2. May a learner be found in breach on a detector’s word?
  3. What must never be put into a tool?

Every course now needs a stated policy on artificial intelligence. Without one, learners guess, and the careful ones are put at a disadvantage against the careless. A policy can be short. It must say four things.

First, what use is allowed. Most instructors sort tasks into three kinds. In some, no use is allowed, because the outcome is the learner’s own unaided skill: a self-check, a sight translation, a first reading of a source. In some, use is allowed with acknowledgement: to find sources, to get an outline criticised, to tidy the English of a draft the learner wrote. In some, use is expected, because working with the tool is what is being taught, as in this course. Say which kind each task is.

Second, that use must be disclosed. A sentence at the end of the work is enough: which tool, and what it was used for. The Federal Court’s form of words is printed below as a model of how simple a disclosure can be. Disclosure is no confession. It is the ordinary honesty of saying how a piece of work was made, as one cites a book.

Third, that the learner answers for everything submitted. Every fact and source must have been verified by the four checks of the last lesson. “The tool said so” is no defence, in a classroom or a court.

Fourth, what must never be given to a tool. This protects other people. No personal information about anyone: no learner’s name with their marks, no family’s line of descent, no record from the Register. Nothing confidential. And nothing that belongs to the Nation’s keeping and is not public. The next lesson explains why that last matters most here.

Three cards, one for each kind of task. Read each from the top: the rule, why, and an example.
No useThe outcome is the learner’sunaided skill.A self-check; a first readingof a sourceUse, acknowledgedThe tool assists; the work isthe learner’s.Finding sources; tidying adraftUse expectedWorking with the tool is whatis taught.Verifying a tool’s sources

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Disclosure” means. Then read on.

The policy binds the instructor as well. Do not paste a learner’s work into a tool to mark it or to test whether a tool wrote it, without their consent. Programs that claim to detect machine-written text are unreliable and have accused honest writers, particularly those writing in a second language. No learner should be found in breach on a detector’s word. If you doubt that work is a learner’s own, talk to them about it. A person who wrote a piece can discuss it.

Disclose your own use. If a tool helped to draft your slides or your feedback, say so, and be able to say that you checked the result. UNESCO’s recommendation of 2021 on the ethics of artificial intelligence, and its guidance of 2023 for education, both put human oversight and responsibility at the centre: a person decides, and a person answers.

Design assessment with the tools in mind. Ask for work on a specific local source the tools know nothing of. Ask for drafts and for the reasoning behind a conclusion. Hold a short conversation about a finished piece. These are good assessment in any case.

Finally, think of fairness. Paid tools are better than free ones, and not every learner can pay. A task that quietly rewards the best subscription is unfair. Either make the tool available to all for that task, or design the task so that it gives no advantage.

The source

Artificial intelligence (AI) was used to generate content in this document.
The declaration the Federal Court of Canada asks for · Federal Court, Notice to the Parties and the Profession: The Use of Artificial Intelligence in Court Proceedings, 20 December 2023.

Key terms

AI policy
A course’s statement of what use of AI is allowed, that it must be disclosed, and who answers for the work.
Disclosure
Saying which tool was used and for what.
Human oversight
The principle that a person decides and a person answers.
Detector
A program claiming to tell machine-written text; unreliable.

Check yourself

1.What four things must a policy say?
2.May a learner be found in breach on a detector’s word?
3.What must never be put into a tool?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: AI policy, Disclosure, Human oversight, Detector.