Courses · DIP 101 Diplomacy, from the ancient world to the embassy · Lesson 3 of 5
Greece, Rome and Byzantium
Lecture 3 of 5 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Who was the proxenos?
- What did Rome require before a war could be called just?
- How did Byzantium survive with too few soldiers?
The Greek world was hundreds of small cities, each independent, sharing a language and quarrelling constantly. It had three kinds of go-between, and each has a descendant today.
The herald carried messages in time of war. He was sacred and could not be harmed, and from him comes the rule that a messenger under a flag of truce is safe. The envoys, chosen by the assembly for one mission, spoke for their city before another city’s assembly; they were orators, and they reported back in public and could be prosecuted if they had done badly. The proxenos was the most original. He was a citizen of one city who looked after the interests of another city in his own: he lodged its visitors, introduced its envoys and spoke up for its people. He is the ancestor of the honorary consul.
The Greeks also made truces for the great games, so that athletes and pilgrims could travel safely, formed leagues with common councils, and sometimes put disputes to a third city to arbitrate. And they left the most searching book ever written about relations between states. Thucydides’ history of the war between Athens and Sparta records, or reconstructs, what envoys actually said. The passage printed below is the Athenian reply to the small island of Melos, which had asked to stay neutral. It is the blunt statement of power against right, and every student of diplomacy has to decide what to make of it. Athens lost that war.
Rome was less interested in equals. But it gave the world two lasting things. One was a college of priests, the fetials, who oversaw the making of treaties and the declaring of war with fixed rites: Rome held that a war was just only if the forms had been kept and a demand for satisfaction had first been made and refused. The other was the idea of a law common to all peoples, the ius gentium, from which later lawyers built the law of nations.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Herald” means. Then read on.
The eastern Roman empire, which we call Byzantium, lasted a thousand years after the west fell, usually with enemies on every border and not enough soldiers. It survived by diplomacy as a system. It kept an office for dealing with foreign peoples. It received envoys with overwhelming ceremony, and it gave titles, robes, gold and sometimes imperial brides to rulers it wished to bind. It kept careful written reports on every neighbouring people, and one emperor wrote a manual on them for his son. Where it could, it set one neighbour against another instead of fighting either. Its envoys were expected to observe everything and report it.
Much of what is now thought of as ordinary diplomatic practice was first worked out at Constantinople: the permanent office, the briefing file, protocol as an instrument of policy, and the envoy as an observer. Venice learned it there and carried it to Italy, where the next lesson begins.
Take one thing from each. From Greece, the envoy answerable in public for what he said. From Rome, the insistence on form: a demand made, a time allowed, an answer recorded, before anything further is done. From Byzantium, the record: a state that cannot outfight its neighbours must know them better than they know it.
The source
You know as well as we do that right, as the world goes, is only in question between equals in power, while the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must.Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, book 5, chapter 89: the Athenian envoys at Melos · Translated by Richard Crawley, 1874.
Key terms
- Herald
- A messenger in time of war, who could not be harmed.
- Proxenos
- A citizen who looked after another city’s interests in his own; the ancestor of the honorary consul.
- Fetials
- Roman priests who oversaw the forms of making treaties and declaring war.
- Ius gentium
- The law Rome held to be common to all peoples; a root of the law of nations.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Herald, Proxenos, Fetials, Ius gentium.