Courses · DIP 101 Diplomacy, from the ancient world to the embassy · Lesson 2 of 5
India and China: statecraft written down
Lecture 2 of 5 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- In Kautilya’s circle of kings, who is a natural friend?
- Which of Sun Tzu’s ways of defeating an opponent is worst?
- What did Kautilya say of the envoy?
Two of the world’s oldest books on how to deal with other powers come from Asia, and both are still read in ministries and staff colleges.
The Arthashastra is a Sanskrit treatise on government attributed to Kautilya, also called Chanakya, minister to the first Maurya emperor in the fourth century BCE. It was lost for centuries and found again in 1905. Its teaching on foreign affairs begins with a picture, the mandala or circle of kings. A ruler’s immediate neighbour is a natural enemy, because their interests touch. The neighbour’s neighbour, on the far side, is therefore a natural friend. Beyond him lies the enemy’s friend, and so on, ring after ring. A small power studies the circle to learn where its allies are to be found.
Kautilya then lists six measures a ruler may take towards another: peace, war, staying quiet, marching, seeking the shelter of a stronger power, and making peace with one while fighting another. The rule for choosing is cold and clear. A ruler who is weaker makes peace; one who is stronger may make war; one who can do neither harm nor good waits. He also names four means of getting one’s way, in the order they should be tried: conciliation, gifts, sowing division, and force last. And he insists that an envoy must not be harmed, whatever message he carries, since the envoy only speaks another’s words.
In China, the centuries before unification in 221 BCE are called the Spring and Autumn and the Warring States periods. Dozens of states competed, and they developed regular practices: sworn covenants between rulers, conferences of states, the exchange of hostages as a guarantee, and travelling advisers who sold their skill in persuasion from court to court.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Arthashastra” means. Then read on.
From this world came The Art of War, attributed to Sun Tzu. Soldiers read it as a book about fighting, and it is at least as much a book about how not to have to fight. Its most quoted line is printed below. Its third chapter ranks the ways of defeating an opponent. Best is to upset his plans. Next best is to break up his alliances. Next is to attack his army. Worst is to besiege his cities. Diplomacy comes first and second on that list, before any battle.
Later Chinese dynasties dealt with their neighbours through what historians call the tributary system. Foreign rulers sent envoys with gifts, acknowledged the emperor’s standing, and received richer gifts and the right to trade in return. Each side could describe the arrangement to its own people in its own way, which is one reason it lasted. When a people on the frontier was too strong for that, the Han court made peace by marriage and by annual payments, and called the other ruler a brother.
Set Kautilya and Sun Tzu beside the Amarna letters and a pattern is plain. Gifts come before threats. Alliances are counted before armies. And a people that is small beside its neighbours need not be helpless, provided it knows the circle it stands in and chooses its friends well. The Mohawk of the eighteenth century, placed between a French empire and an English one, would have understood every word.
The source
Hence to fight and conquer in all your battles is not supreme excellence; supreme excellence consists in breaking the enemy’s resistance without fighting.Sun Tzu, The Art of War, chapter III · Translated by Lionel Giles, 1910.
Key terms
- Arthashastra
- A Sanskrit treatise on government attributed to Kautilya, fourth century BCE.
- Mandala
- Kautilya’s circle of kings: the neighbour is an enemy, the neighbour’s neighbour a friend.
- The four means
- Conciliation, gifts, division and force, to be tried in that order.
- Tributary system
- The exchange of envoys, gifts and trade through which Chinese courts dealt with their neighbours.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Arthashastra, Mandala, The four means, Tributary system.