Courses · FAC 102 Designing a course · Lesson 3 of 4
Alignment
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What do learners treat as the real curriculum?
- What does an empty second column show?
- Besides the topic, what must match?
A course can have good outcomes, good lessons and a good final task, and still fail, if the three do not point the same way. The educator John Biggs gave the remedy a name in 1996: constructive alignment. The outcomes say what learners will be able to do. The activities have them practise doing it. The assessment asks them to do it. When all three match, learners know what to work at and the marks measure the right thing.
Misalignment is common, and learners spot it at once. An outcome says “argue a position from the sources”. The classes are lectures. The exam is multiple choice on dates. Learners study dates, as anyone would, since the assessment is what a course really asks for, whatever its outline says. Another writer on teaching, Paul Ramsden, put it bluntly: from the learner’s point of view, the assessment defines the curriculum.
The tool for checking is a table with three columns. In the first, write each outcome. In the second, write where in the course learners practise it. In the third, write where it is assessed. Then read across. An outcome with nothing in the second column is assessed without being taught. One with nothing in the third is taught and never checked. An activity or a test question that matches no outcome is a passenger.
Check the level as well as the topic. If the outcome says “evaluate two readings” and the practice is reading a summary of them, the topic matches and the level does not. Learners will meet evaluation for the first time in the final task. Use Bloom’s six levels on each row: the verb in the outcome, the thinking in the activity and the thinking in the assessment should be the same.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Constructive alignment” means. Then read on.
Check the weights too. The University’s evaluation scheme is printed below. Its heaviest part is the final essay or brief, which is where the higher outcomes are shown. A course whose main outcome is an argument, and which gives most of its marks to recall, is misaligned by arithmetic.
The University aligns its courses in public. Each course’s page shows its outcomes with the level of thinking each asks for, and its curriculum map shows the outside standards those outcomes meet. The course-structure audit then checks, for every course, that the parts are present. You can see where your own course stands before you teach it.
Alignment is also the heart of the best-known standard for online courses, which FAC 107 treats: its reviewers look first for whether outcomes, materials, activities and assessments support one another.
To finish this lesson, build the table for one course. It takes about an hour, and it is the most useful hour you will spend on a course. Bring the table to your Chair: it is the first thing they will want to see.
The source
Self-checks, every lesson: 15 per cent. Primary-source analysis: 25 per cent. Seminar or moot participation: 15 per cent. Final essay or brief: 45 per cent.The University’s evaluation scheme · As printed on every official course description of Mohawk University.
Key terms
- Constructive alignment
- Outcomes, activities and assessment all pointing the same way.
- Alignment table
- Three columns: each outcome, where it is practised, where it is assessed.
- Passenger
- An activity or test question that serves no outcome.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Constructive alignment, Alignment table, Passenger.