Courses · FAC 102 Designing a course · Lesson 1 of 4
Outcomes
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Which is a sound outcome verb?
- What is at the top of the revised taxonomy?
- What should happen to an outcome you will not assess?
A course begins with a statement of what a learner will be able to do at the end of it. That statement is an outcome. Everything else in the course exists to bring it about or to show that it has been reached.
The test of an outcome is whether you could watch someone do it. “Explain the difference between a pledge and a proclamation” can be watched. “Understand the Haldimand instruments” cannot: understanding happens inside a head, and two markers will never agree on whether it took place. So an outcome starts with a verb of action. Explain, compare, draft, calculate, trace, prove and argue are such verbs. Understand, know, appreciate and be aware of are not.
Verbs differ in how much they ask. In 1956 a committee chaired by Benjamin Bloom sorted the aims of education into levels, and a revision in 2001 gave the six that most colleges now use. In rising order they are remember, understand, apply, analyse, evaluate and create. To list the four instruments is remembering. To explain what each does is understanding. To use them on a new set of facts is applying. To find the assumption in an opponent’s argument is analysing. To judge which of two readings is better supported is evaluating. To draft a new instrument is creating.
The levels are a tool for checking a course. If every outcome sits at the bottom, the course is a memory test. If every one sits at the top, beginners will sink. A first course should have most of its outcomes in the lower half with one that reaches higher. The University’s four levels follow the same climb: the outcomes for young learners begin with say and name, and those for law school with assess and draft.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Outcome” means. Then read on.
Write few outcomes. Three to five are right for a course of four to six lessons. An outcome you do not intend to assess should be cut, since it promises something you will never check.
Write them for the learner. “You will be able to read a Record Code” is better than “Students will demonstrate competence in the identification of record identifiers”. The University writes to the international standard for plain language, and outcomes are where that matters most, because they are the first thing a learner reads.
Ontario’s colleges also write outcomes to a provincial list of essential employability skills: communication, numeracy, critical thinking and problem solving, information management, interpersonal skills and personal skills. Each of the University’s official course descriptions names the ones the course develops. It is a useful discipline to ask of any course what a learner will be able to do afterwards that an employer or a community would notice.
The University’s own rule is printed below. Hold your draft outcomes against it, one by one, and replace every verb that fails.
The source
Every course must state its learning outcomes, each beginning with a verb that can be observed.Learning outcomes · Draft Directive on the University’s standards and credits; proposed, for adoption by the Gazette.
Key terms
- Outcome
- A statement of what a learner will be able to do, beginning with a verb that can be observed.
- Bloom’s taxonomy
- Six levels of thinking: remember, understand, apply, analyse, evaluate, create.
- Essential employability skills
- Ontario’s list of general skills that college courses are written to develop.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Outcome, Bloom’s taxonomy, Essential employability skills.