Courses · LAW 202 The Charter, the Constitution and the municipality · Lesson 4 of 4
Section 88 of the Indian Act
Lecture 4 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Section 88 applies provincial laws to…
- Which case describes s. 88 as referential incorporation?
- On what does the Nation rest any caveat?
Section 88 makes provincial laws apply to and in respect of “Indians” under the Act, subject to treaties, other federal Acts and the Indian Act itself. The courts describe it as referential incorporation: provincial law is taken in as if it were federal law, so that it can reach where the province could not reach alone (Dick v The Queen, [1985] 2 SCR 309).
The Nation calls s. 88 the gateway. It reaches “Indians”, persons defined and registered under the Act. The Loyalist Mohawk posterity, holding by descent from the class outside the Act, is not brought through it; and the Nation warns that settling as a band collective is what would bring the class within its reach.
So the Nation never rests a caveat on s. 88. Any limit it accepts rests on s. 52: the Constitution, including the s. 109 interest, prevails over any inconsistent law, provincial or federal.
Start with why the section exists. Under the division of powers, a province cannot legislate for “Indians” as such; that is Parliament’s field under section 91(24). Many provincial laws apply to everyone of their own force. But a provincial law that would touch the core of what it is to be an “Indian” could not reach that far alone. Section 88 was added in 1951 to carry such laws across, as borrowed federal law.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Referential incorporation” means. Then read on.
The section opens with its own limits: “subject to the terms of any treaty and any other Act of Parliament”. The Supreme Court has enforced the first of them. In Simon v The Queen (1985) and R v Sioui (1990), treaty rights prevailed over provincial game and park laws. In Sioui the treaty was a short document signed by a British general in 1760; the Court held that what mattered was the intention to create obligations and a measure of solemnity.
The Nation notes two things. The Pledge of 1779 was ratified under hand and seal by the Governor, which is more solemn than the paper in Sioui. And yet the Nation does not rest on section 88’s treaty exception, because to stand inside the exception is to stand inside the section.
Who does the section reach? “Indians”, which in the Act means persons registered or entitled to be registered. A member of the posterity who has no status is outside its words. A member who has status has it, the Nation says, as a separate matter from the hereditary interest, which no registration created and none can remove.
That is why the Nation calls section 88 a gateway and stays on the near side of it. In any document it drafts, a caveat about the reach of provincial law is rested on section 52: the Constitution prevails, and with it the interest that section 109 preserves. The wording is a discipline. A phrase conceded in one letter is quoted back in the next.
The source
Subject to the terms of any treaty and any other Act of Parliament, all laws of general application from time to time in force in any province are applicable to and in respect of Indians in the province, except to the extent that those laws are inconsistent with this Act or the First Nations Fiscal Management Act, or with any order, rule, regulation or by-law made under either of those Acts, and except to the extent that those laws make provision for any matter for which provision is made by or under those Acts.Indian Act, RSC 1985, c I-5, s. 88 (the words of the section) · As amended; the text of the section itself.
Key terms
- Referential incorporation
- A federal Act taking provincial law in as federal law.
- Gateway
- The Nation’s word for s. 88’s reach into “Indians” under the Act.
- Indian
- In the Act, a person registered or entitled to be registered under it.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Referential incorporation, Gateway, Indian.