Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · LAW 202 The Charter, the Constitution and the municipality · Lesson 3 of 4

Down to the municipality

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Where do a municipality’s powers come from?
  2. Does the Charter bind a municipality?
  3. Whose is the duty to consult?

Municipalities are not named in the Constitution as governments of their own. Section 92(8) gives the provinces “municipal institutions in the province”, so a city is created by provincial statute and holds only the powers the province gives it. In Ontario that statute is the Municipal Act, 2001.

Because a municipality acts with the province’s power, the Charter binds it too: the Supreme Court said so in Godbout v Longueuil, [1997] 3 SCR 844. And the duty to consult belongs to the Crown, not to a municipality: Neskonlith Indian Band v Salmon Arm, 2012 BCCA 379.

The Nation’s reading follows the chain. A municipality can hold no more than the province gave it; the province took its lands subject to “any Interest other than that of the Province” (s. 109); so a by-law or a tax levied on the Tract meets that interest, and s. 52 decides any inconsistency.

Follow one by-law down the chain. A city council passes it under a power in the Municipal Act, 2001. The Municipal Act is a statute of the Ontario Legislature, made under section 92 of the Constitution Act, 1867. The Legislature’s power over land in the province runs, for public lands, through section 109. Each link is only as strong as the one above it.

The chain of authority from the Constitution to a city hall. Read from the top: no layer can hold more than the layer above gave it.
The ConstitutionSections 92 and 109: the province’s powers, and its lands subject to other interests.The Province of OntarioMakes the Municipal Act, 2001 and the Assessment Act.The municipalityHolds only delegated power.A by-law or a taxCarries every limit above it.

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Municipal institution” means. Then read on.

The Municipal Act says as much about conflict: a by-law is without effect to the extent that it conflicts with a provincial or federal Act. And the Charter cases say it about rights. In Godbout a city required its employees to live within its limits; the Supreme Court held that the Charter applied, because a municipality exercises governmental power that the province delegated to it. A province cannot escape the Constitution by handing a task to a city.

Property tax follows the same chain. A municipality taxes land under the Assessment Act and the Municipal Act, both provincial. If the province’s own hold on the land is burdened by an interest that section 109 preserves, the Nation says, the power delegated downward carries the same burden.

What a municipality does not carry is the Crown’s honour. In Neskonlith the British Columbia Court of Appeal held that a city owed no duty to consult a First Nation about a development permit; the duty lies with the Crown. The Nation finds that instructive in two ways. A city is not the party to deal with on the main question. And yet a city’s officials, having sworn the oath, remain bound to observe the Constitution in what they do.

So the Nation writes to municipalities in a particular way. It does not ask a council to decide who owns the Tract. It asks whether the council accepts that it is liable to observe the Proclamation as a duty imposed by law, and it registers the answer, or the silence.

Key terms

Municipal institution
A city, town or county created under provincial law (s. 92(8)).
By-law
A law made by a municipality within its delegated powers.
Delegated power
Power given by a higher authority, never greater than its source.

Check yourself

1.Where do a municipality’s powers come from?
2.Does the Charter bind a municipality?
3.Whose is the duty to consult?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Municipal institution, By-law, Delegated power.