Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · ECO 102 Accounts and assurance · Lesson 3 of 4

Who checks?

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What is the central rule of internal control?
  2. What does an audit give?
  3. What can a daily proof of reserves not show by itself?

Books that balance show that the arithmetic is right. They do not show that the entries are true. For that, someone other than the bookkeeper has to look. The article printed below states the principle in a sentence: society may require an account of every public agent. This lesson is about the three lines of checking that give the sentence force.

The first line is internal control: the arrangement of the work so that errors and theft are hard. Its central rule is the separation of duties. The person who approves a payment does not make it, and the person who makes it does not record it. No one handles a transaction alone from start to finish. The Register’s rule that a record is approved by a second officer is the same principle applied to records. Other controls are limits on what one person may approve, regular reconciliation of the books with the bank’s statements, and a trail that shows who did what and when.

The second line is internal audit: people inside the organisation, apart from those who run the daily work, who test whether the controls are being followed and report to those at the top.

The third is external audit, by someone independent. An auditor examines a sample of transactions and the evidence behind them, tests the controls, confirms balances directly with banks and others, and gives an opinion. The opinion comes in four kinds. An unmodified opinion says the statements present the position fairly. A qualified opinion says so with a stated exception. An adverse opinion says they do not. A disclaimer says the auditor could not obtain enough evidence to tell. Read which it is before you read anything else.

Three cards, one for each line of checking. Read each from the top: who checks, what they do, and to whom they report.
Internal controlDuties are separated; no oneacts alone.Built into the daily workInternal auditTests whether the controlsare followed.Reports to those at the topExternal auditAn independent opinion on theaccounts.Reports to those the treasuryanswers to

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Internal control” means. Then read on.

An audit gives reasonable assurance and no guarantee. It works by sampling, and a determined fraud with forged documents can defeat it. Its worth depends on the auditor’s independence: appointed by and reporting to someone other than the people being audited, and with nothing to gain from a favourable result. In parliamentary countries this is the office of the Auditor General, who reports to the legislature and not to the government.

What of a proof published every day, as ECO 101 describes? It is a strong control of an unusual kind, since anyone can check it, and it shows what it shows: that on a given day the assets stated were at least equal to the liabilities stated. It has limits that an honest treasury names. It is a snapshot. It shows the liabilities that were listed, and cannot by itself show that none was left out. And it does not show who controls the account. Exchanges that published such proofs have still failed. For that reason the standard-setters ask for an independent accountant’s examination of the whole, under the international standard for assurance engagements, as well as the published proof.

For the Nation’s Treasury the benchmark is therefore plain, and this course states it as a benchmark and not as a description: daily proof, separation of duties, an auditor independent of the Treasury, and the opinion published in full. A member is entitled to ask which of the four are in place.

Checking is not an accusation. Honest bookkeepers want it most, because it is their only means of showing that they are honest.

The source

Society has the right to require of every public agent an account of his administration.
Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, 1789, article 15 (in translation) · National Constituent Assembly of France, 26 August 1789.

Key terms

Internal control
Arranging work so that errors and theft are hard, above all by separating duties.
Audit
An independent examination of accounts, ending in an opinion.
Unmodified opinion
An auditor’s statement that the accounts present the position fairly.
Proof of reserves
A published showing that stated assets cover stated liabilities at a point in time.

Check yourself

1.What is the central rule of internal control?
2.What does an audit give?
3.What can a daily proof of reserves not show by itself?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Internal control, Audit, Unmodified opinion, Proof of reserves.