Courses · ECO 102 Accounts and assurance · Lesson 2 of 4
Reading a government’s accounts
Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What does the statement of financial position show?
- Why is accrual accounting more honest than cash?
- Where is much that an organisation would not dwell on?
A people that pays into a treasury is entitled to know what was done with the money. The article printed below, from 1789, puts it as a right of citizens. Exercising it takes the ability to read a set of accounts, which is less difficult than the people who write them sometimes make it seem.
Governments around the world increasingly report to one set of rules, the International Public Sector Accounting Standards. A government following them publishes, each year, four main statements and a set of notes.
The statement of financial position is a picture on one day, usually the last of the year. It lists what the government has, what it owes, and the difference, its net assets. It is the accounting equation, set out for the reader. Look at what is owed and when it falls due, and at whether net assets are growing or shrinking.
The statement of financial performance covers the year. It lists revenue, by source, and expenses, by purpose, and the surplus or deficit between them. Ask where the money came from and what it was spent on, and compare with the year before.
The statement of changes in net assets explains how the difference between the two years’ positions came about. The cash flow statement shows the money that actually moved in and out of the bank. It matters because a government can show a surplus and still run out of cash, or the reverse.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Statement of financial position” means. Then read on.
That last point turns on the basis of accounting. On a cash basis, a transaction is recorded when money moves. On an accrual basis, it is recorded when the right or the obligation arises, whether or not money has moved yet: a bill received in March is a March expense even if paid in May, and a pension promised is a liability today. Accrual accounting is harder and far more honest, since it shows what has been promised as well as what has been paid. The international standards ask for it.
A fifth document compares the budget with what happened. A budget is a plan approved in advance by whoever has authority to approve spending. The comparison shows whether the plan was kept, and where it was not. It is the most useful single page for a citizen.
Then read the notes. They say what rules were followed, what the big numbers are made of, what has been promised but is not yet in the figures, and what might go wrong. Much that an organisation would prefer not to dwell on is in the notes.
The International Monetary Fund publishes a code on fiscal transparency that sets out what an open government reports: full accounts, forecasts and budgets, and the risks it faces. Canada and Ontario publish Public Accounts each year, with an auditor’s opinion.
For any treasury, including the Nation’s, a member might ask five questions. What does it hold, and where? What does it owe, and to whom? What came in this year, and what went out? Was that what was planned? And who, independent of the people who kept the books, has checked them? The next lesson is about that last question.
The source
All citizens have the right to ascertain, by themselves or through their representatives, the need for a public tax, to consent to it freely, to watch over its use, and to determine its proportion, basis, collection and duration.Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, 1789, article 14 (in translation) · National Constituent Assembly of France, 26 August 1789.
Key terms
- Statement of financial position
- What an organisation has and owes on one day.
- Statement of financial performance
- Revenue and expenses over a year.
- Accrual basis
- Recording a transaction when the right or obligation arises, not when money moves.
- Budget
- A plan of revenue and spending approved in advance.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Statement of financial position, Statement of financial performance, Accrual basis, Budget.