Courses · RES 305 Writing and defending the research essay · Lesson 1 of 4
An argument
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What makes a thesis good?
- What is a warrant?
- How should the strongest objection be treated?
What you will be able to do
- Write an arguable thesis.
- Name the parts of an argument.
- Meet the strongest objection.
Unit 17 of 20 · the plan
- Before the session1½ h
- The lesson1½ h
- The case½ h
- The seminar1½ h
- The check¼ h
- Hand in¾ h
About6 hours
A research essay is an argument: a claim that a reasonable person could doubt, supported by reasons and evidence. It is neither a report of everything you read nor a statement of what you believe. Aristotle, in the passage printed below, said that persuasion rests on three things: the character of the speaker, the frame of mind of the hearers, and the proof. A research essay leans on the third. The first still counts. Your care with sources is your character on the page.
The claim is called the thesis. It is the answer to your research question, in one sentence. It must be arguable and exact. “The Proclamation of 1784 is important” is neither. “The Patent of 1793 changed three terms of the Proclamation of 1784, and each change narrowed what had been promised” is both. Whether it is true is what the essay must show.
An argument has working parts, and a philosopher of the last century named them. The claim. The grounds: the evidence for it. The warrant: the reason the grounds support the claim, which writers often leave unsaid and readers often doubt. The qualifier: how sure you are. And the rebuttal: the conditions under which the claim would fail. Write out the warrant for each main point. If you cannot, the point is not yet made.
Evidence comes in the kinds this term has taught: documents, testimony, numbers, and the judgment of those who know. Quote each exactly and weigh it as you were taught. An argument is as strong as its weakest piece of evidence, so say plainly which pieces are strong and which are thin.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Thesis” means. Then read on.
Then turn on your own case. State the strongest objection as its holders would state it, and answer it or grant it. This University teaches each position of the Nation with who contests it, and an essay written here does the same. A case that has met its best opponent is believed. One that has met only a weak version persuades only its friends.
Avoid the common false moves. Attacking the person and not the reasoning. Answering a weaker claim than the one made. Leaning on an expert outside their field, which CIV 103 taught you to catch. Taking what came after for what was caused, which RES 304 taught. And choosing only the evidence that agrees.
Claim what the evidence will bear and no more. “The surviving record suggests” is a stronger sentence than “it is certain”, because the reader can see that you know the difference.
For this lesson, write your thesis in one sentence. Beneath it set out three points, each with its grounds and its warrant. Then write the strongest objection in three sentences, as fairly as its holder would.
The source
Of the modes of persuasion furnished by the spoken word there are three kinds. The first kind depends on the personal character of the speaker; the second on putting the audience into a certain frame of mind; the third on the proof, or apparent proof, provided by the words of the speech itself.Aristotle, Rhetoric, book 1, part 2 · Translated by W. Rhys Roberts (1924).
This lesson as a unit
Before the session1½ hours
Read. Aristotle, Rhetoric; Stephen Toulmin, The Uses of Argument.
Bring 150 words. What is your warrant?
The case: The project file½ hour
The project file. Your own research essay of 2,500 words, carried from a topic to its defence; each unit adds to the file what its lesson asks. Write the thesis, three points with grounds and warrants, and the strongest objection as its holder would state it.
The seminar1½ hours, live
Pairs find each other’s unstated warrants.
Hand in: casebook entry 17 · An argument45 minutes
The argument plan. Marked to a published guide, with written feedback in three parts: what the evidence supports, what is still assumed, and what to do next.
Key terms
- Thesis
- The essay’s answer to its question, in one sentence.
- Warrant
- The reason the evidence supports the claim.
- Counter-argument
- The strongest case against the thesis, fairly stated.
- Qualifier
- A word that says how sure the writer is.
The questions of this lesson
- Choose oneWhat makes a thesis good?
- It is long
- Nobody could doubt it
- It is arguable and exact
- Choose oneWhat is a warrant?
- A footnote
- The reason the evidence supports the claim
- A court order
- Choose oneHow should the strongest objection be treated?
- Stated weakly
- Left out
- Stated as its holders would state it, then answered or granted
They are answered and marked in My Register, where this sample lesson is open to every member: there it asks 8 questions in all, in four ways, with how sure you are and what is still unclear. No answers are published on this site.
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Thesis, Warrant, Counter-argument, Qualifier.
Sample questions of the test →
This was the sample lesson
Writing and defending the research essay has three more lessons, each with its reading, its terms and its self-check, and a test drawn from the whole course. They are for enrolled learners, in My Register.
The first lesson is open to everyone. The full course is $60, and free for members of the Nation. What it costs