Courses · CIV 201 The honours of the Nation · Lesson 2 of 4
Nominating
Lecture 2 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Who may nominate?
- A good nomination includes…
- A nomination is weighed…
Anyone may nominate someone for an honour. A good nomination says what the person did, for whom, over how long, and who can confirm it.
Nominations are entered in the Register like any other application, and weighed the same way.
The book sets out how the Roll of Honour would work, as a proposal for the Gazette to adopt. A nomination may be made by any officer or resident, in writing, with a citation of no more than 200 words. The limit is deliberate: a citation says what was done, plainly, and a short one cannot hide behind adjectives.
The nomination is reviewed by an honours panel of three, none of whom has an interest in the nominee. That is the ethics rule applied to honours: no one sits in judgment on a relative, a partner or a patron.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Nomination” means. Then read on.
Conferral is by the Gazette, with the citation, a Record Code, and an entry on the Ledger. An honour, in other words, is an instrument like any other, and it can be found and checked like any other. Withdrawal is possible only by the Gazette, with reasons, for conduct that brings the Roll into disrepute.
The book’s worked entry gives the flavour of a good citation: “For thirty years of keeping the Grand River’s level records, and teaching them.” It names the service, its length and what made it more than a job.
A nomination moves through five standings: nominated, reviewed, and then conferred, declined or withdrawn. The book’s reason for doing all this by Gazette is the heart of the matter: an honour no one can quietly give or take away.
The book compares the design with others and answers the questions a critic would ask, and its answers come back to two ideas. First, an honour is only as good as the process behind it: if friends can honour friends, the Roll is worth nothing, which is why the panel must have no interest in the nominee. Second, an honour must be public to mean anything: the citation is published so that anyone can judge whether it was deserved. When you write a nomination for this course, write it for that reader, the stranger who will see the name on the Roll in fifty years and wonder why it is there. Give them the answer in plain words, and give the panel the names of two people who can confirm it.
The source
For thirty years of keeping the Grand River’s level records, and teaching them.A worked citation · Honours, Heraldry and Ceremony, Book VI, “The Roll of Honour” (illustration).
Key terms
- Nomination
- A proposal that someone be honoured.
- Roll of Honour
- The published list of those honoured.
- Citation
- The statement, in 200 words or fewer, of what was done.
- Honours panel
- Three reviewers, none with an interest in the nominee.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Nomination, Roll of Honour, Citation, Honours panel.