Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · MAP 101 Six miles deep · Lesson 3 of 4

How big is the Tract?

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Which figure is the Nation’s reference for the whole Tract?
  2. Where does the 760,000-acre figure appear?
  3. Why do the figures differ?

Several numbers are given and each is a different thing. The Nation takes some 950,000 acres as its reference for the full Tract, mouth to source, as the Proclamation describes it.

The Crown’s own plaque at Her Majesty’s Chapel of the Mohawks gives 760,000 acres granted. Ridout’s 1821 survey gave 674,910 acres, with its northern limit at the Falls near Elora. The reserve today is some 46,000 to 48,000 acres.

Each figure is cited for what it is. None is wrong on its own terms; they measure different things.

Start with the largest. The Nation’s reference of some 950,000 acres is the area of the whole band, from the mouth to the source. It is the answer to the question the Proclamation poses: how much land lies within six miles of each bank of the Grand?

The Crown’s plaque at the Mohawk Chapel says 760,000 acres. It does not show its working, but the figure is the Crown’s own, published in bronze, and the Nation cites it for exactly that: it is what the Crown has said.

Four figures for the Tract. Each row says how many acres, whose figure it is, and what it measures.
AcresWhoseWhat it measuresAbout 950,000The NationThe whole band, mouth to source760,000The Crown’s plaqueAs granted to the Mohawk674,910Ridout, 1821To the Falls near Elora,straight limits46,000 to 48,000The reserve todayWhat remained in the band’sname

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Survey” means. Then read on.

Thomas Ridout, the Surveyor General, reported 674,910 acres in 1821. His survey stopped at the Falls of the Grand near Elora and did not go on to the source, so it measured a shorter Tract, and with straight limits. It is a real survey of a part.

The reserve today is about 46,000 to 48,000 acres, depending on the year and the source. It is what remained in the band’s name after the sales, leases and surrenders of the nineteenth century, whose validity the Nation disputes.

One more figure belongs in any honest account: what the Nation holds in hand today, which is nothing. The Crown claims the Tract and the reserve is held under the Indian Act. The Nation’s claim is in right, over the whole, and it says so plainly so that no one mistakes a claim for possession.

When you cite a number for the Tract, say which it is and whose. “About 950,000 acres, as the Proclamation describes it” and “674,910 acres, by Ridout’s survey of 1821” are both true statements. “The Tract was 675,000 acres” on its own is not, because it hides the choice.

A useful exercise is to set the four figures out as fractions of the first. The plaque’s figure is about four fifths of the whole band; Ridout’s about seven tenths; the reserve about one twentieth. Set out that way, the argument over the figures becomes an argument about what each one measures.

Key terms

Reference figure
The number the Nation uses for the whole Tract.
Survey
A measurement made on the ground, with its own limits.
In right
Claimed by title, as distinct from held in hand.

Check yourself

1.Which figure is the Nation’s reference for the whole Tract?
2.Where does the 760,000-acre figure appear?
3.Why do the figures differ?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Reference figure, Survey, In right.