Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · RES 302 Research ethics, and who owns the knowledge · Lesson 1 of 4

Why research has rules

Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What does the first point of the Nuremberg Code require?
  2. What happened to the Havasupai samples?
  3. Which three questions come before any study?

What you will be able to do

  • Say why research has rules.
  • Know the cases behind them.
  • Ask the three questions before any study.

Unit 5 of 20 · the plan

  1. Before the session1½ h
  2. The lesson1½ h
  3. The case½ h
  4. The seminar1½ h
  5. The check¼ h
  6. Hand in¾ h

About6 hours

Research can harm the people it studies. The rules that govern it were not thought up in advance. Each was written after a wrong, and to know the wrongs is to understand the rules.

In 1946 and 1947 an American military court at Nuremberg tried physicians who had experimented on prisoners in the camps of Nazi Germany. Its judgment, in August 1947, set out ten points on permissible experiments. The first is printed below, and its opening sentence has governed research ever since: the voluntary consent of the human subject is absolutely essential.

A code did not end the wrongs. From 1932 to 1972 the United States Public Health Service followed some four hundred Black men in Alabama who had syphilis, in order to study the disease untreated. The men were not told what they had, and they were not given penicillin when it became the ordinary cure. A newspaper exposed the study in 1972. In 1979 a commission answered with the Belmont Report, which named three principles: respect for persons, beneficence, and justice.

Indigenous peoples have their own cases. Between 1990 and 1992 more than two hundred members of the Havasupai Tribe, in Arizona, gave blood for what they understood to be research on diabetes at a state university. The samples were later used for studies of schizophrenia, of migration and of inbreeding. The Tribe learned of it in 2003. In April 2010 the university agreed to pay $700,000 to forty-one members and to return the samples, which the members took back.

The line runs from 1947 to 2022. Filled circles are codes and policies. Open circles are cases that showed why they were needed.
1947The NurembergCode1972The Alabamastudy exposed1979The BelmontReport1998First TCPS;OCAP set out2010Havasupaisamplesreturned2022TCPS 2,current

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Harm” means. Then read on.

Cases like that explain a distrust that researchers still meet. For generations research was done on Indigenous peoples and not with them. Their words, their blood and their belongings were taken away, the findings were printed elsewhere, and the people were described by others. A Māori scholar wrote that research is one of the dirtiest words in the Indigenous world’s vocabulary. A researcher who begins by knowing that history begins well.

In Canada the three federal bodies that fund research issued one policy in 1998, revised it in 2010, and last reissued it in 2022. It is known as TCPS 2. A university or hospital that takes their funds must have each study with people reviewed by a research ethics board before it begins. The next lessons are drawn from that policy and from the principles First Nations have set beside it.

Ethics is more than a form to be signed. Before any study, ask three things. Who could be harmed by this, and how? Have they agreed, knowing what it is? And who benefits? This University holds itself to the same test. It keeps nothing a learner writes in a lesson, and it counts lessons completed without names.

For this lesson, choose one of the three cases. In half a page, say what was done, which of the three questions was never asked, and what rule now stands in its place.

The source

The voluntary consent of the human subject is absolutely essential. This means that the person involved should have legal capacity to give consent; should be so situated as to be able to exercise free power of choice, without the intervention of any element of force, fraud, deceit, duress, over-reaching, or other ulterior form of constraint or coercion; and should have sufficient knowledge and comprehension of the elements of the subject matter involved as to enable him to make an understanding and enlightened decision.
The Nuremberg Code (1947), point 1 · Trials of War Criminals before the Nuremberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law No. 10, volume 2 (Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1949).

This lesson as a unit

Before the session1½ hours

Read. The Nuremberg Code; The Belmont Report.

Bring 150 words. Who could be harmed, have they agreed, and who benefits?

The case: The project file½ hour

The project file. Your own research essay of 2,500 words, carried from a topic to its defence; each unit adds to the file what its lesson asks. Ask the three questions of your own study and enter each answer.

The seminar1½ hours, live

Groups take one case each and name the question never asked.

Path A · starting outThe three questions, one answered.
Path B · officers and professionalsWrite the half page on one case.

Hand in: casebook entry 5 · Why research has rules45 minutes

The three questions of your study. Marked to a published guide, with written feedback in three parts: what the evidence supports, what is still assumed, and what to do next.

Key terms

Informed consent
Agreement given freely by a person who knows what is asked and what it may bring.
Research ethics board
A body that reviews a study with people before it begins.
Harm
Any injury to a person or a people: to body, standing, privacy or trust.
TCPS 2
The policy of Canada’s three federal research funders on research with people.

The questions of this lesson

  1. Choose oneWhat does the first point of the Nuremberg Code require?
    1. The voluntary consent of the person
    2. A university’s approval
    3. A large sample
  2. Choose oneWhat happened to the Havasupai samples?
    1. They were lost
    2. They were used for studies the members had not agreed to
    3. They were never tested
  3. Choose oneWhich three questions come before any study?
    1. How long, how much, how many
    2. Who pays, who publishes, who reads
    3. Who could be harmed, have they agreed, and who benefits

They are answered and marked in My Register, where this sample lesson is open to every member: there it asks 8 questions in all, in five ways, with how sure you are and what is still unclear. No answers are published on this site.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Informed consent, Research ethics board, Harm, TCPS 2.

Sample questions of the test →

This was the sample lesson

Research ethics, and who owns the knowledge has three more lessons, each with its reading, its terms and its self-check, and a test drawn from the whole course. They are for enrolled learners, in My Register.

The first lesson is open to everyone. The full course is $60, and free for members of the Nation. What it costs