Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · HIS 201 From the Pledge to the Register, 1779 to 1796 · Lesson 3 of 4

1793 and 1796

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Which instrument does the Nation keep outside the four?
  2. What did the 1796 Proclamation provide?
  3. Why does the Nation call the missing ascertainment a root?

On 14 January 1793 Simcoe issued a patent for the Grand River lands. The Nation holds that the Mohawk of the Grand rejected it: it was not for their exclusive benefit and would have turned their grant into a collective holding.

On 6 April 1796 Simcoe’s Register Proclamation provided for those entitled to be ascertained on oath before magistrates. The Nation holds that this was never done for the Mohawk class, and that the missing step is the root of every later doubt.

So the Nation counts four instruments, 1779, 1784, 1789 and 1796, and keeps the 1793 Patent outside them.

By 1791 the old Province of Quebec had been divided, and Upper Canada had its own government under John Graves Simcoe. Brant wanted the Grand River lands confirmed in a form that would let the Six Nations lease and sell to settlers, for income. Simcoe wanted the opposite: a title that kept the land from passing to anyone but the Crown.

The Patent of 14 January 1793 was Simcoe’s answer. It granted to the chiefs, warriors, women and people of the Six Nations, and it forbade them to sell or lease except to the Crown. Historians agree that Brant refused it. The Nation’s reading goes further: the Patent was not for the Mohawk’s exclusive benefit, it described a collective holding under the Crown’s protection, and by refusing it the Mohawk kept what the Proclamation had already given.

Two instruments of the 1790s, side by side. Compare what each was, and what became of it.
The Patent, 1793To the Six Nations collectivelyNo sale or lease except to the CrownOffered to Brant, and refusedThe Nation sets it asideThe Register Proclamation, 1796To settle the U.E. rollProof on oath before magistratesCarried out for settlersNever carried out for the Mohawk class

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Patent” means. Then read on.

The Proclamation of 6 April 1796 dealt with a different problem, the U.E. list. Claims had multiplied, and Simcoe required those claiming the Mark of Honour to prove their right on oath before the magistrates in quarter sessions, so that the roll could be settled.

For the settlers that was done, district by district. For the Mohawk class, the Nation says, it was not, and no roll of them was made.

So the two instruments of the 1790s stand in contrast. One was offered and refused, and the Nation sets it aside. The other was proclaimed and, for the class, never carried out, and the Nation asks that it be.

A fair account notes what is uncertain. The Nation says that in 1791 a committee agreed on two instruments for the Grand River lands, of which the Patent was one, and that the other was never established; it has not yet published its source for that. Until it does, a student should report the claim as the Nation’s, and look for the minute.

Key terms

Patent
A Crown grant of land under the Great Seal.
Ascertainment
Establishing on oath who belongs to a class.
Magistrate
A justice of the peace, before whom oaths are taken.

Check yourself

1.Which instrument does the Nation keep outside the four?
2.What did the 1796 Proclamation provide?
3.Why does the Nation call the missing ascertainment a root?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Patent, Ascertainment, Magistrate.