Courses · HIS 303 Newcomers and the trade, 1609 to 1664 · Lesson 1 of 4
1609: the shot on the lake
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Who wrote the only account of the fight of 1609?
- Why is “one shot made a hundred and fifty years of war” too simple?
- What happened six weeks later, to the south-east?
What you will be able to do
- Read a one-sided source for what it had no reason to invent.
- List what its writer had reason to enlarge.
- Explain why one shot did not make a century of war.
Unit 5 of 20 · the plan
- Before the session1½ h
- The lesson1½ h
- The case½ h
- The seminar1½ h
- The check¼ h
- Hand in¾ h
About6 hours
Late in July 1609 Samuel de Champlain and two other Frenchmen travelled south with a war party of about sixty Innu, Algonquin and Wendat men, whom he called Montagnais, Algonquins and Hurons. On the lake that now carries his name they met some two hundred warriors. Champlain called them Iroquois, and historians take them to have been Mohawk. The two sides agreed to fight in the morning. What followed is printed below in his own words.
He says his gun was loaded with four balls, that two chiefs fell and a third man was mortally hurt, and that when one of his companions fired from the trees the Mohawk broke and ran. They had not met guns in battle before. His allies took ten or twelve prisoners.
This is the only account. It was written by the man who fired, and printed in Paris in 1613 for readers whose money and favour he needed. The engraving that went with it shows palm trees, because the engraver had never seen the place. No Mohawk account written at the time exists. Even the place is disputed: historians have argued for Ticonderoga and for Crown Point.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Wendat” means. Then read on.
A one-sided source is still evidence. Ask what he had no reason to invent. He had every reason to enlarge the number of the enemy and the effect of his shot. He had none to invent the manner of the meeting: two bodies of men drawn up in order, leaders walking in front, a fight agreed for the morning. That detail shows a way of making war with rules, which guns were about to change.
It is often said that this one shot made the Five Nations the enemies of France for a hundred and fifty years. That is too simple. The Mohawk and their northern neighbours were at war before Champlain came, which is why his allies brought him. And war was broken by peace, in 1624, 1645, 1653, 1667 and 1701. What the summer of 1609 did show was what a newcomer’s weapons were worth to whoever had him as an ally.
The Mohawk did not wait long to find allies of their own. Six weeks after the fight, in September 1609, Henry Hudson sailed up the river that carries his name, in the service of Dutch merchants, to a point near the present Albany. A second people of newcomers was now two or three days’ walk south-east of the Mohawk towns, with the same goods and the same guns to trade.
The source
I marched on until I was within some thirty yards of the enemy, who as soon as they caught sight of me halted and gazed at me and I at them. When I saw them make a move to draw their bows upon us, I took aim with my arquebus and shot straight at one of the three chiefs, and with this shot two fell to the ground and one of their companions was wounded who died thereof a little later.Samuel de Champlain on the fight of July 1609 · The Works of Samuel de Champlain, edited by H. P. Biggar (Toronto: Champlain Society, 1925), volume 2, 89–101, as given by History Matters (George Mason University). The punctuation between the confirmed phrases is supplied.
This lesson as a unit
Before the session1½ hours
Read. Champlain’s account as the lesson prints it, in The Works of Samuel de Champlain, edited by H. P. Biggar.
Bring 150 words. List three things Champlain had reason to enlarge, and one he had no reason to invent.
The case: The three villages, 1609 to 1784½ hour
The warriors on the lake in 1609 are taken by historians to have been Mohawk. No Mohawk account written at the time exists. Record in your casebook what the source says of them, what it cannot say, and that this is the first written record of the people the case follows.
The seminar1½ hours, live
Read the account three times: once for numbers, once for the manner of the meeting, once for what is missing. Each reading goes on a separate sheet; the three sheets are compared.
Hand in: casebook entry 5 · A one-sided source45 minutes
What Champlain had no reason to invent, in five lines, each tied to his words. Marked to a published guide, with written feedback in three parts: what the evidence supports, what is still assumed, and what to do next.
Key terms
- Arquebus
- An early gun, fired from the shoulder.
- Wendat
- The people the French called Huron.
- Innu
- The people the French called Montagnais.
- One-sided source
- An account from one party only, read for what it had no reason to invent.
The questions of this lesson
- Choose oneWho wrote the only account of the fight of 1609?
- Champlain, who fired the shot
- A Dutch trader
- A Mohawk speaker
- Choose oneWhy is “one shot made a hundred and fifty years of war” too simple?
- It happened in 1709
- The shot missed
- The war was older than Champlain, and peace was made several times after
- Choose oneWhat happened six weeks later, to the south-east?
- Hudson sailed up the river for Dutch merchants
- The English took Albany
- The league was made
They are answered and marked in My Register, where this sample lesson is open to every member: there it asks 8 questions in all, in four ways, with how sure you are and what is still unclear. No answers are published on this site.
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Arquebus, Wendat, Innu, One-sided source.
Sample questions of the test →
This was the sample lesson
Newcomers and the trade, 1609 to 1664 has three more lessons, each with its reading, its terms and its self-check, and a test drawn from the whole course. They are for enrolled learners, in My Register.
The first lesson is open to everyone. The full course is $60, and free for members of the Nation. What it costs