Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · REG 201 Keeping a record · Lesson 2 of 4

Weighing evidence

Lecture 2 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Which usually weighs most?
  2. Two sources give different birth years. The officer should…
  3. Evidence that answers the question only when combined with other facts is…

Not all evidence weighs the same. An original record made at the time by someone with no reason to shade it weighs more than a copy, and a copy more than a recollection told many years later.

Genealogists separate the source (the document), the information in it (first-hand or second-hand) and the evidence it gives for a particular question (direct or indirect). An officer uses the same habits.

Where two sources disagree, the officer does not choose the convenient one. The conflict is stated, each source is weighed, and the reasoning is written into the file.

Apply the habit to the birth registration. The best evidence is a record made at the time by someone who was there: a notice from the midwife or hospital, signed and dated. A baptismal entry made weeks later is good. A relative’s statement years afterwards is evidence too, but it is weaker, and the file should say so.

The Register’s forms each follow a recognised standard for their work, and name it on the form. For vital events it is the United Nations’ Principles and Recommendations for a Vital Statistics System. The standards are why another country’s court or registry can rely on what the Nation’s officers record.

How evidence weighs. The three cards run from the strongest kind to the weakest.
Made at the timeA notice signed by someonewho was there.Weighs mostMade soon afterA baptismal or church entry.Weighs wellTold years laterA relative’s recollection ordeclaration.Evidence, and marked as such

Where the evidence is thin, the officer has three honest courses. Ask for more, and say what is needed. Enter what can be proved, and mark what cannot as not yet documented. Or return the application with the reason. What an officer may never do is supply the missing fact from sympathy, or from what “everyone knows”.

A statutory declaration has a particular place. Where no record exists, a person may declare the fact solemnly before a Registry Officer who is a Commissioner for Oaths. The declaration is evidence, and it is the declarant’s evidence: the file records that the fact rests on a declaration, and by whom.

Finally, write the reasoning down. A decision with its reasons can be checked, corrected and defended. A decision without them can only be trusted or distrusted, and a register cannot rest on that.

The Guide teaches by contrast, under the heading “Good work, and work that is not”. Read its examples for your own office. This course’s rule of thumb is the same idea: good work names its evidence, says what was checked against what, and leaves nothing for the next reader to guess, where poor work says “verified” and no more. When you write a note on a file, ask whether a stranger could repeat your check from what you wrote.

Key terms

Original source
A record in its first form, made at or near the time.
Primary information
Given by someone with first-hand knowledge.
Direct evidence
Answers the question on its own; indirect evidence needs combining with more.
Statutory declaration
A solemn statement of fact made before a Commissioner for Oaths.

Check yourself

1.Which usually weighs most?
2.Two sources give different birth years. The officer should…
3.Evidence that answers the question only when combined with other facts is…

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Original source, Primary information, Direct evidence, Statutory declaration.