Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · REG 202 Ethics, conflicts of interest and the oath · Lesson 3 of 4

Conflicts of interest

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. A Teller who owns a café handles the café’s deposit. That is…
  2. Within how long must a change be declared?
  3. What does the public register show?

A conflict of interest arises when a private interest could touch an official duty. The Nation’s rules follow the OECD’s Guidelines for Managing Conflict of Interest in the Public Service, and they distinguish three kinds.

An actual conflict is a private interest that does touch a decision now. The book’s example: a Lands officer asked to approve a boundary for their cousin’s farm. An apparent conflict is one a fair observer would think touches the decision, even if it does not: a Teller who owns a café that takes Grand River dollars, handling the café’s deposit. A potential conflict is one that could touch a decision later: an officer whose spouse is applying for a loan next month.

The book gives a short tree to work through. Could my decision help or harm me, my family, or a business I am part of? If yes: declare it, and step aside from that decision. Would a fair observer think it could? If yes: declare it, and ask your superior whether to step aside. Might it arise later? Declare it now, so it is on record before it matters. None of these? Go ahead, and the record shows you asked.

Notice that an apparent conflict is treated almost as seriously as an actual one. That surprises new officers. The reason is that the Register’s value lies in being trusted. A decision that was in fact fair, but that any observer would doubt, damages that trust nearly as much as an unfair one.

Three kinds of conflict. Each card gives the kind, the book’s own example, and what to do.
ActualA Lands officer asked toapprove a boundary for acousin’s farm.Declare, and step asideApparentA Teller who owns a café,handling the café’s deposit.Declare, and ask your superiorPotentialAn officer whose spouse willapply for a loan next month.Declare it now

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Apparent conflict” means. Then read on.

Declarations are made on joining an office, before acting in it; every year, on the anniversary of joining; and within fourteen days of any change. Each is approved by the officer’s superior, and the Inspection Division sees every declaration.

Part of each declaration is public and part is private. The public register shows that a declaration is made, its date, and the offices and businesses declared, with any decision the officer steps aside from. Amounts, addresses and details of family members are seen only by the officer’s superior and the Inspection Division. The public learns enough to judge; the officer’s family keeps its privacy.

The book prints a specimen declaration, filled in for an invented Lands officer: she is treasurer of a beadworkers’ circle, owns a beadwork business, holds a lease on the Tract, and steps aside from the boundary review of her brother’s lot, with her Director’s approval and its date. Nothing in it is shameful. That is the point of a declaration: ordinary interests, stated plainly, before they matter.

Key terms

Actual conflict
A private interest that touches a decision now.
Apparent conflict
One a fair observer would think touches it.
Potential conflict
One that could touch a decision later.
Step aside
To take no part in a decision, on the record.

Check yourself

1.A Teller who owns a café handles the café’s deposit. That is…
2.Within how long must a change be declared?
3.What does the public register show?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Actual conflict, Apparent conflict, Potential conflict, Step aside.