Courses · FAC 108 Cultural diversity in the classroom · Lesson 2 of 4
Seeing your own assumptions
Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What is wrong with “I treat everyone the same”?
- What should you do about an unfamiliar name?
- How should you take correction?
People do not arrive at respect for difference in one step. The American scholar Milton Bennett described six stages that people move through, and they are useful as a mirror. In denial, a person does not notice difference at all, or thinks of other cultures as vague and far away. In defence, they notice and feel threatened: our ways are right and theirs are worse. In minimisation, they insist that people are all the same underneath, which sounds generous and quietly makes their own culture the standard. In acceptance, they recognise that other ways are as coherent as their own. In adaptation, they can change how they act to fit another way. In integration, moving between ways has become part of who they are.
Most well-meaning instructors are at minimisation. “I treat everyone the same” is its motto. But treating everyone the same means treating everyone as though they were like you, and the learners who are not pay for it.
Three habits of mind do most of the damage, and everyone has them. A stereotype is a fixed belief about a group applied to a person: she is Indigenous, so she will know about ceremony. An assumption is a guess treated as knowledge: he is quiet, so he has not done the reading. Bias is a lean in judgment that you do not notice in yourself. Studies in many countries have found that the same piece of work is marked differently when a different name is put at the top.
Then there are slights: small remarks and acts that tell a person they do not quite belong. Each is trivial and their sum is not. Classroom examples are easy to find. Getting a name wrong all term because it is unfamiliar. “Where are you really from?” “You don’t look Mohawk.” “You speak so well.” Turning to the one Indigenous learner whenever an Indigenous topic comes up. Praising a learner for being unlike the rest of their group. The speaker usually means well, and usually cannot see why it stung. The person on the other end has heard it a hundred times.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Stereotype” means. Then read on.
What can be done about habits you cannot see? Several things, none of them dramatic. Learn names in the first week, ask how they are said, and say them properly. A name is the first thing a person has. In this University that includes Kanien’kéha names, which keep their marks and are written as given. Mark work without names where you can, and by the rubric. Keep a tally for a week of whom you call on and whom you praise; the pattern is seldom what you expected. Ask a colleague to watch a class and tell you what they saw.
And when you are told you have got something wrong, take it well. Say “thank you for telling me”, put it right and do not ask the person to manage your embarrassment. An instructor who can be corrected without a scene makes a room in which everyone can.
The Commission called for training of this kind for public servants, in the sentence printed below. It asked for skills. Good intentions it took for granted. The difference is that a skill is something you can practise and get better at.
The source
This will require skills-based training in intercultural competency, conflict resolution, human rights, and anti-racism.Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, Call to Action 57 · Calls to Action, 2015; the second sentence of the Call.
Key terms
- Stereotype
- A fixed belief about a group, applied to an individual.
- Bias
- A lean in judgment that a person does not notice in themselves.
- Minimisation
- Insisting that people are all the same underneath, which makes one’s own culture the standard.
- Slight
- A small remark or act that tells a person they do not quite belong.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Stereotype, Bias, Minimisation, Slight.