Courses · HIS 302 Before the written record: the Mohawk and the league · Lesson 1 of 4
What can be known, and how
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Which kind of evidence gives dates and details but was written by strangers?
- What does this course do where a lesson reaches what the Confederacy’s keepers carry?
- What can the ground not tell an archaeologist?
What you will be able to do
- Name the three kinds of evidence for the time before 1609, and the chief limit of each.
- Explain why this course stops where the Confederacy’s keepers begin.
- Say what the Supreme Court of Canada held about memory as evidence.
Unit 1 of 20 · the plan
- Before the session1½ h
- The lesson1½ h
- The case½ h
- The seminar1½ h
- The check¼ h
- Hand in¾ h
About6 hours
This term course is a survey of the Mohawk, and of the Confederacy to which they belong, from the earliest evidence to 1783, where HIS 201 takes up the story. Two cautions come first. The course is written from published sources: printed documents, the work of historians and archaeologists, and what Haudenosaunee writers have themselves put in print. And the Mohawk Nation of Grand River does not speak for the Confederacy. Where a lesson reaches what the Confederacy’s own keepers carry, it says so and stops. The course awaits review by a knowledge keeper, and it will be corrected by what that review finds.
Three kinds of evidence bear on the time before newcomers wrote. The first is what the people carry: accounts handed down of how the league was made, of names, places and relations. It is carried by people trained to carry it, in the languages, and recited before others who can correct the speaker. Its limits, for a historian from outside, are two. It is not hers to take. And it keeps what matters for the people’s own purposes, which is seldom a date in a foreign calendar.
The second is what the ground holds. Archaeologists read the stains left by house posts, storage pits, the lines of palisades, pottery, pipes and burnt kernels of maize, and date them by radiocarbon. From these they can say where a town stood, how large its houses were, and that towns moved every ten to twenty years as fields and firewood gave out. The ground is silent on names, words and law. And digging disturbs places and the dead, which is why it is now done by agreement with the people concerned, as RES 302 sets out, or not done.
The third is what newcomers wrote: the French from 1609, the Dutch from the 1620s, the English from 1664. Their papers are dated and detailed. They were also written by strangers, few of whom spoke the language, for superiors and sponsors at home. They saw the men’s councils and missed much of the women’s authority. They named what they saw in their own terms: castle, king, nation, sachem. Every such word is a translation, and some are mistakes.
A sound account uses all three, and says at each step which one it rests on. Where they agree, the finding is strong. Where they differ, the writer says so and does not choose the one she likes. That is the triangulation taught in RES 303, applied to four centuries.
The paragraph printed below is from Canada’s highest court. It comes from a case on Aboriginal title, a road the Nation does not take for its own interest, as LAW 201 explains. It is printed here for what it says about evidence: that what a people carries by memory is to be weighed on an equal footing with documents. Historians were slower than the court to accept this, and some still resist it.
The source
Notwithstanding the challenges created by the use of oral histories as proof of historical facts, the laws of evidence must be adapted in order that this type of evidence can be accommodated and placed on an equal footing with the types of historical evidence that courts are familiar with, which largely consists of historical documents.Delgamuukw v. British Columbia, [1997] 3 S.C.R. 1010, paragraph 87 · Supreme Court of Canada; Lamer C.J.
This lesson as a unit
Before the session1½ hours
Read. The source the lesson prints, from Delgamuukw, and the opening of Daniel K. Richter, The Ordeal of the Longhouse.
Bring 150 words. Name one thing about your own family that you know only because someone told you. How should a historian weigh it?
The case: The three villages, 1609 to 1784½ hour
The case begins. The Pledge of 1779 names three villages: Canojaharie, Tikondarago and Aughugo, as it spells them. This term follows the Mohawk towns from the earliest evidence to the day those names are written. Open your casebook with the three names, and three questions you will carry to the end: where their people lived before, who spoke for them, and how anyone knows.
The seminar1½ hours, live
Three tables, one for each kind of evidence. Each says what its evidence can show about a Mohawk town of about 1600, and what it cannot. Then the room puts the three together and marks where they agree.
Hand in: casebook entry 1 · The question and the three kinds of evidence45 minutes
One page: your three questions, and for each, which kind of evidence could answer it and what would limit the answer. Marked to a published guide, with written feedback in three parts: what the evidence supports, what is still assumed, and what to do next.
Key terms
- Oral tradition
- What a people carries by memory and recital, through those trained to carry it.
- Archaeology
- The study of the past from what is left in the ground.
- Documentary record
- What was written at the time: here, by newcomers.
- Triangulation
- Testing a finding against more than one kind of evidence.
The questions of this lesson
- Choose oneWhich kind of evidence gives dates and details but was written by strangers?
- Archaeology
- The documentary record
- Oral tradition
- Choose oneWhat does this course do where a lesson reaches what the Confederacy’s keepers carry?
- It says so and stops
- It replaces it with a historian’s version
- It prints it in full
- Choose oneWhat can the ground not tell an archaeologist?
- What the people called themselves
- How large a house was
- Where a town stood
They are answered and marked in My Register, where this sample lesson is open to every member: there it asks 8 questions in all, in four ways, with how sure you are and what is still unclear. No answers are published on this site.
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Oral tradition, Archaeology, Documentary record, Triangulation.
Sample questions of the test →
This was the sample lesson
Before the written record: the Mohawk and the league has three more lessons, each with its reading, its terms and its self-check, and a test drawn from the whole course. They are for enrolled learners, in My Register.
The first lesson is open to everyone. The full course is $60, and free for members of the Nation. What it costs