Courses · FAC 109 A safe place of study · Lesson 2 of 4
Consent and power
Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Is silence consent?
- May an instructor have a romantic relationship with a learner they assess?
- What should an instructor do if their partner enrols?
Consent is the centre of the subject, and it is simpler than it is sometimes made to seem. The Criminal Code’s definition is printed below: consent is voluntary agreement to the activity in question.
Five things follow, and trainings in every college teach them. Consent is active. It is given by words or conduct that show agreement, and silence or the absence of a refusal is not consent. It is specific: agreement to one thing is not agreement to another. It is ongoing, and can be withdrawn at any moment, at which point the other person must stop. It must be given by the person themselves, and nobody can consent on another’s behalf. And it requires capacity: a person who is asleep, unconscious, or too affected by alcohol or drugs to understand what is happening cannot consent.
The Code adds a point that bears directly on teachers. There is no consent where a person is induced to take part by someone abusing a position of trust, power or authority.
An instructor holds exactly such a position. You decide marks. You write references. You may decide whether a certificate is recommended. A learner who is asked for something by a person with that power cannot refuse as freely as they could refuse an equal, and both of you know it. Agreement given under those conditions may not be voluntary at all, and even where it is, nobody else can be sure of it: the other learners in the class cannot, and the learner, looking back, may not be either.
For that reason the University’s proposed rule is simple, and it is the rule in most colleges. An instructor does not enter a romantic or sexual relationship with a learner they teach, supervise, assess or advise. It makes no difference who began it or how willing both appear. If a relationship already exists when a person enrols, as with a spouse or partner, the instructor tells the Chair at once and takes no part in teaching or marking that person.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Consent” means. Then read on.
The rule reaches smaller conduct as well. Do not comment on a learner’s appearance or body. Do not ask about their relationships. Do not make sexual jokes, in class or in messages. Do not touch a learner beyond a handshake that is offered. Do not single out one learner for private attention, gifts or late-night messages. None of this is prudishness. Each is how the misuse of power usually begins, and each is experienced by the learner as something they are not free to object to.
Power also runs between learners, between older and younger, and between people who hold office in the Nation and those who do not. The same understanding applies to all of it. The freer a person is to say no, the more their yes means.
Alcohol deserves a plain word. Many incidents at colleges involve it. At any gathering connected with a course, an instructor is at work and behaves as such. Being drunk does not excuse a failure to make sure of consent, and it does not make a person who was harmed responsible for what was done to them.
If you are ever unsure whether something you are about to say or do is appropriate, ask whether you would do it in front of your Chair and the learner’s family. If you would not, you have your answer.
The source
Subject to subsection (2) and subsection 265(3), consent means, for the purposes of sections 271, 272 and 273, the voluntary agreement of the complainant to engage in the sexual activity in question.Criminal Code of Canada, section 273.1(1): the meaning of consent · R.S.C. 1985, c. C-46. Printed as the definition Canadian trainings teach.
Key terms
- Consent
- Voluntary agreement to the activity in question; active, specific, ongoing and given with capacity.
- Capacity
- Being awake, aware and able to understand what is happening.
- Position of trust
- A role, such as a teacher’s, that gives one person power over another.
- Boundary
- A limit on conduct that keeps a professional relationship professional.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Consent, Capacity, Position of trust, Boundary.