Study · Standards · Course outlines
Standards
Course outlines: how they work elsewhere, and ours beside them
How a course outline looks and works at an Ontario college and at eight other institutions, and what ours takes from each. Then four of Cambrian College’s courses, three in Indigenous Studies and one in computer applications, set beside our own outcome by outcome.
A comparison is a measure and not an endorsement. The College has not reviewed these courses and grants no credit for them. Its outlines are its own. They are described here in our words, from the copies read on 20 November 2026.
Of the College’s 20 outcomes, our courses teach 1, teach 7 in part, and do not yet teach 12.
The form of an outline
The table lists what a college outline contains. Read across: the part, where ours has it, and whether we had it, have now added it, or have it only in part. What was added is on every course’s outline for institutions.
| A college outline has | Ours | Standing |
|---|---|---|
| Title, code, credit value and hours | Official course description and outline. One University credit is ten learner hours (proposed). | Have |
| The programmes a course belongs to | Now named on every outline: the certificates and term courses that use the course. | Added |
| Prerequisites and equivalencies | Prerequisites are stated. Equivalent courses elsewhere are for the Chair to decide, one by one. | In part |
| General education theme | Now named on every outline, by Ontario’s five themes. Proposed. | Added |
| Course description | The calendar description. | Have |
| Approval: by whom, on what date, for which terms | The approval block of the official description. Every course is still marked as a draft awaiting its Chair. | In part |
| Relationship to programme outcomes | Each outcome is tied to a level of Bloom’s taxonomy and an Ontario Degree Level Expectation. | Have |
| Topics and concepts covered | The schedule of lessons, each with its source. Key terms are now listed lesson by lesson. | Added |
| Learning outcomes, with objectives under each | Outcomes are stated. Objectives are now given lesson by lesson, as the three questions each lecture answers. | Added |
| Essential employability skills, in six categories | Now on every outline, each category marked as applying or not. | Added |
| Delivery method and learning activities | Now on every outline. | Added |
| Evaluation plan: weights and a grading scheme | Weights are stated. A letter scale and a pass mark are proposed in the draft directive. | Proposed |
| Learning resources | Each course lists its reading, and every lesson prints its primary source. | Have |
| Policies | Academic integrity, accessibility, Indigenous knowledge and privacy. | Have |
| Recognition of prior learning; transfer credit | Now stated on every outline, with a page on how to ask: by challenge, by portfolio, or by speaking or doing it. | Added |
| A content warning where the material may distress | Now on FAC 109. It will be needed on any lesson about the residential schools. | Added |
| The outline as one document, dated and approved | Every course now has a course outline to print, in the Nation’s page standard, with its approval block. | Added |
How outlines look and work elsewhere
Nine institutions and systems, in four countries and one nation’s college. Read across: who, what its outline must hold, and how the outline works once it is given.
| Institution | What its outline must hold | How it works |
|---|---|---|
| Cambrian College An Ontario college | One form for every course: description, programme outcomes, topics, outcomes with objectives, six employability skills, general education themes, delivery, an evaluation plan with a grading scheme, then the College’s policies. | Approved by the Chair of the school, dated, and good for named terms. Students are told to keep it for transfer and employment. |
| University of Waterloo An Ontario university | Required elements, from the instructor’s contact to the weight and deadline of each piece of work and the rules for group and late work; and required statements on integrity, grievance, discipline, appeals and accommodation. | The statements are the same in every outline, so every student is told the same rights. |
| University of Toronto An Ontario university | The methods of evaluation, their weights and their timing must be disclosed no later than the last date to enrol. | After that they cannot be changed without the consent of a majority of the students present. No one piece of work may count for more than 80 per cent, and marked work worth at least 10 per cent must come back before the last date to withdraw. |
| McMaster University An Ontario university | Contact, objectives, materials and what they cost, each requirement with its weight, how work is handed in, the rules on missed and late work, and a set of approved statements. | Available as the course begins, and kept on file for ten years. Changes need notice, an explanation and a chance to comment. No one item above 75 per cent without approval, and early feedback before the last date to drop. |
| University of British Columbia A Canadian university | A Senate policy lists twelve things a syllabus must hold, among them learning outcomes, learning activities, materials and their cost, assessment and its rules, and a statement on the use of generative AI. | Given within the first week. A material change later needs a reason given to the class, a revised and dated version, and notice. |
| The European credit system (ECTS) The European Higher Education Area | Sixteen items for every course unit in a catalogue, from code and credits to learning outcomes, teaching methods, assessment criteria and the language of instruction. | Credit is counted by the learner’s whole workload: 25 to 30 hours to a credit, and 60 credits to a year. |
| University of Nottingham A university in the United Kingdom | A module specification: credits and level, a summary, requisites, method of delivery, learning outcomes, activities, assessment, reading, and a note on content that may be sensitive. | One credit is ten notional hours of a student’s effort, in class and out. The specification is part of the university’s regulations and must be kept to. |
| University of Technology Sydney A university in Australia | A subject outline with name and number, credit points, requisites, staff, objectives, teaching activities, assessment, and what is needed to pass. | Available no later than the Monday before the first week. The faculty board approves the description, and its procedures say which changes need its approval. |
| Diné College The college of the Navajo Nation | A checklist of eleven items. One of them is the college’s own philosophy of education, which every syllabus must work into the course: thinking, planning, living and assuring. | A nation’s college writes its own way of knowing into every outline, beside the items every college has. |
What they have in common
- A governing body sets what every outline must hold. It is not left to each teacher.
- The outline is given before the course begins, or in its first week.
- Once given, it binds. How a course is assessed cannot be changed without notice, and at one university without the students’ consent.
- Limits protect the student: more than one assessment, a cap on any single piece of work, and early feedback.
- The same statements of rights appear in every outline: integrity, accommodation, appeal, and now the use of AI.
- Outlines are dated, approved and kept, because students need them years later.
- Credit is counted in hours: of teaching in Ontario’s colleges, and of all study in Europe and the United Kingdom.
- A nation’s own college writes its own way of knowing into the outline.
Ours, checked item by item
The table lists every item those nine ask of an outline, 46 in all, and where ours stands. Ours meets 34, meets 8 by a rule that is proposed and not yet adopted, meets 2 in part, and does not yet meet 2. Read across: the item, who asks for it, what ours says, and its standing.
| Item | Who asks for it | Ours | Standing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Code, title, credit and hours | All of them | Stated. | Met |
| Level of study | Europe, Nottingham | Four levels, and the international level of the outline. | Met |
| Whether the course is required or optional | Europe | The programmes that require it are named. | Met |
| Prerequisites and equivalent courses | Cambrian, British Columbia, Europe, Sydney | Prerequisites stated. Equivalents are decided case by case. | Met |
| Course description | All of them | Stated. | Met |
| Learning outcomes that can be observed | All of them | Stated, each with its level. | Met |
| Outcomes tied to assessment | Diné College | Each outcome is checked in the self-checks and drawn on in the final task. | Met |
| A schedule of topics | Waterloo, McMaster, British Columbia, Diné College | The lessons in order, with a suggested pace. | Met |
| When and where the course is given | Waterloo, British Columbia | At any time, online. | Met |
| The teacher’s name | Waterloo, McMaster, British Columbia, Europe, Nottingham, Sydney, Diné College | No teacher or Chair is yet named. | Not yet |
| How and when to reach the teacher | Waterloo, McMaster, British Columbia, Diné College | The study address, with a reply within two working days. No named person. | In part |
| Learning activities and teaching methods | British Columbia, Europe, Nottingham, Sydney | Stated, with the six parts of a lesson. | Met |
| The workload in hours | Europe, Nottingham | Stated, part by part. | Met |
| Required reading and resources | All of them | Stated. | Met |
| What the materials cost | McMaster, British Columbia, Diné College | Stated: nothing. | Met |
| The technology needed | Cambrian, Diné College | Stated: a web browser. | Met |
| Each piece of work, its weight and what it is | All of them | Stated. | Met |
| The task described, with its rubric | McMaster, Diné College | The final task at each level; the rubric is in the Teacher’s guide. | Met |
| More than one assessment, and a cap on any one piece | Toronto, McMaster | Four kinds of work; the largest is 45 per cent. A cap of one half is proposed. | Met |
| Early feedback | Toronto, McMaster, Diné College | A self-check in every lesson, marked at once. | Met |
| A grading scale | Cambrian, Toronto, Diné College | The scale Ontario’s colleges use. | Proposed |
| What is needed to pass | Sydney | Fifty per cent; a programme may ask for more. | Proposed |
| Late and missed work | Waterloo, Toronto, McMaster, British Columbia | No penalty in a self-paced course. A missed seminar is taken again or replaced. | Met |
| How work is handed in and returned | Waterloo, McMaster | Stated. No one is yet named to mark a learner who studies alone. | In part |
| Rules for group work and taking part | Waterloo, McMaster | Each learner is marked for their own part. | Proposed |
| Re-marking and appeal | Waterloo, British Columbia | The marker, then a second marker through the Chair, then the Dean. | Proposed |
| Complaints | Waterloo | To the Chair, then the Dean. | Proposed |
| Integrity, and how a breach is dealt with | Waterloo, McMaster, British Columbia | Stated, after FAC 103. | Met |
| The use of AI | British Columbia | Stated, after FAC 105. | Proposed |
| Detection and proctoring software | Waterloo, McMaster, Cambrian | Stated: none is used. | Met |
| Accommodation for disability | Waterloo, McMaster, Diné College | Stated. | Met |
| Accommodation for observance | McMaster | A seminar is moved for a ceremony, observance or bereavement. | Met |
| Another way to show an outcome | Nottingham | Stated. | Met |
| Conduct | McMaster, Cambrian, Diné College | Stated. | Met |
| Copyright and recording | McMaster, Cambrian | Stated. | Met |
| A note on distressing content | Nottingham, Cambrian | Stated where it applies. | Met |
| Work with people | McMaster | Consent before an interview; a story by permission of its teller. | Met |
| Help and services | British Columbia, Cambrian | A page of services for learners, each marked as open or still to be staffed. | Met |
| Recognition of prior learning; transfer | Cambrian | Stated on every outline. Standing for a course taken elsewhere, and assessment of learning from work and life by challenge or portfolio, are rules of the draft directive. | Proposed |
| Given before the course begins | Toronto, McMaster, British Columbia, Sydney | Always published. | Met |
| Changes after a learner has begun | Toronto, McMaster, British Columbia | A new version; a change to assessment does not reach a learner who has begun. | Proposed |
| Dated, numbered by version, and kept | Cambrian, McMaster | Version and date stated; every version kept. | Met |
| Approved by a named authority | Cambrian, Nottingham, Sydney | The approval block is there. Nobody has yet signed. | Not yet |
| The institution’s own way of knowing | Diné College | The Nation’s positions taught in the course, and who contests each. | Met |
| Language of instruction | Europe | Stated. | Met |
| Credit by hours of all study | Europe, Nottingham | Ten learner hours to a University credit: the United Kingdom’s count. | Met |
How much study
The two institutions count differently, and no conversion is claimed. The table gives each one’s own figures.
| Institution | Credit | Hours |
|---|---|---|
| Cambrian College, each of the four | 3 credits | 42 credit hours, which count time in class |
| Mohawk University, one course | 1.5 University credits (proposed) | 14 to 17 learner hours, which count all study |
| Mohawk University, one term course | 12 University credits (proposed) | About 120 learner hours, with 36 seminar hours |
Intro to Indigenous Studies IND1003 · 3 credits · 42 hours
An introduction to Indigenous peoples in Canada: heritage, culture and history from creation to today, seen through an Indigenous worldview. It covers colonization, the Treaty relationship, the Indian Act and the residential schools, with resilience and resistance, and the journey toward reconciliation. Its teachings are Anishinaabe ones.
General education theme: Social and cultural understanding; Personal understanding.
| The College’s outcome | Where our courses teach it | Standing |
|---|---|---|
| Worldviews and history from creation to the present: Indigenous and European worldviews; the Anishinaabe Creation story and the Seven Grandfather Teachings; customs and places. | HIS 101 and HIS 201 teach the Loyalist Mohawk’s history from the three villages to 1796, and ART 101 what the people made. SET 101 lessons 1 and 2 set out the settler worldview. No creation account or ceremonial teaching is given: the draft directive bars teaching anything sacred or restricted, and such teaching would be for a knowledge keeper. | In part |
| The effect of colonial policy and Canadian law: treaties, colonization, residential schooling, the Sixties Scoop and child welfare, and the Indian Act. | SET 101 lessons 2 to 4 teach the ideas, the tools and the present workings of a colony. LAW 301 teaches whom the Indian Act was written for and how it removed people. DIP 102 teaches the Covenant Chain. The residential schools, the Sixties Scoop and child welfare are not yet taught. | In part |
| Barriers and solutions to nation-to-nation relationships: the treaties; resistance such as the Constitution Express, Kanesatake and Ipperwash; and the responses, among them section 35, the Royal Commission and the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. | DIP 102 and DIP 301 teach the Nation’s own dealing with the Crown, nation to Crown. LAW 201 teaches the Nation’s footing, which is a Crown grant under sections 109 and 52 and is not section 35. The events of 1990 and 1995 and the Royal Commission are not taught. | In part |
| The resilience of leaders past and present, the place of culture and identity, and the role of an ally. | HIS 101, HIS 201 and DIP 102 teach Joseph Brant and the leaders of the three villages. ART 101 and ART 102 teach the makers and Pauline Johnson, and CIV 201 the Nation’s honours. The role of an ally is not taught as such. | In part |
What ours adds. Our courses turn the lens: SET 101 takes the settler society as its subject. They teach from the four Crown instruments, and they say of every position whose it is and who contests it.
Standing. Complementary. Neither covers the other. One is a general introduction from Anishinaabe teachings; the other is the history and law of the Loyalist Mohawk of three villages. A learner gains from both.
Truth and Reconciliation IND1012 · 3 credits · 42 hours
A study of Canada’s residential school system within settler colonialism: the policies and attitudes that let it work, the harm it did and still does, and the present efforts toward reconciliation, restitution and restoration. The outline opens with a warning that the material may distress.
General education theme: Social and cultural understanding; Civic life; Personal understanding.
| The College’s outcome | Where our courses teach it | Standing |
|---|---|---|
| The factors, policies and character of the residential school system. | Not yet taught. SET 101 lesson 2 gives the ideas behind it: discovery, improvement, wardship and enfranchisement. A lesson on the Mohawk Institute is waiting until it is settled who should be part of writing it. | Not yet |
| The effects on families and communities, from Survivors’ own accounts. | Not yet taught. FAC 106 lesson 4 teaches instructors how to teach a painful history without harming those who lived it. | Not yet |
| Cultural genocide, trauma passed between generations, and wellness across generations. | Not yet taught. | Not yet |
| Many views of reconciliation; the Doctrine of Discovery and terra nullius; the Commission’s Final Report; Indigenous-led resistance. | REC 101 teaches the Nation’s own view, which is reconciliation on the record. SET 101 lesson 2 teaches the doctrine of discovery. The Commission’s Calls to Action are named where they bear on a course: 28, 57, 67 and 86. | In part |
| Actions toward reconciliation, and one’s own part in them. | REC 101 lesson 4 and SET 101 lesson 6 set out what the Nation asks: that the instruments be observed and the record completed. CIV 102 lesson 4 sets a civic action project. | In part |
What ours adds. REC 101 treats reconciliation as the keeping of promises already made and recorded. That is a different subject from the schools, and it does not replace it.
Standing. Complementary, and the gap is ours: the University does not yet teach the residential schools.
Indigenous Perspectives on Care IND1062 · 3 credits · 42 hours
The health and well-being of Indigenous peoples from creation to the present and beyond: culture, spirituality and traditional healing, what determines Indigenous health today, and how to give care that is culturally safe. It is taught to practical nursing students among others.
General education theme: General education; no theme named.
| The College’s outcome | Where our courses teach it | Standing |
|---|---|---|
| Health before contact, and what colonization did to it: ways of knowing, cultural safety, historical trauma. | Not taught. FAC 108 teaches culture and assumptions, for instructors. | Not yet |
| The lasting effects on health; the determinants of health; decolonizing care. | Not taught. | Not yet |
| Indigenous views of health and wellness, and models of care. | Not taught. | Not yet |
| The Commission’s Calls to Action on health. | Not taught. | Not yet |
What ours adds. Nothing yet. The University has no faculty of health.
Standing. No course of ours corresponds.
Computer Applications CMP1011 · 3 credits · 42 hours
Basic skill in the common computer applications: entering, storing and working with data, managing files, checking the quality of information, and making reports and presentations. It is taught with one maker’s word processor, spreadsheet, presentation and database programs.
General education theme: None; a vocational course.
| The College’s outcome | Where our courses teach it | Standing |
|---|---|---|
| The parts of a personal computer, and how devices connect. | Not taught. | Not yet |
| The web and online information: searching, judging a website, the uses of AI, and online threats. | CIV 102 lesson 3 teaches how to check a source, and CIV 103 how to test an expert. FAC 105 teaches the use of AI. REG 203 lesson 3 teaches passwords, devices and phishing. | Taught |
| Managing files: names, folders and backups. | Not taught as a skill. The Style Book sets a rule for file names. | Not yet |
| Documents: revising with tracked changes, references, long reports with contents and styles. | PUB 102 lessons 2 and 4 teach editing and the structure of an accessible document. The tools themselves are not taught. | In part |
| Spreadsheets: formulas, tables, charts and summaries. | Not taught. ECO 102 teaches double entry and how to read accounts, on paper. | Not yet |
| Presentations. | Not taught. | Not yet |
| Databases: combining sources, queries and forms. | Not taught. REG 101 and REG 201 teach the Register as a record, and MAP 102 lesson 3 one open data format. | Not yet |
What ours adds. Nothing yet beyond the lessons named.
Standing. No course of ours corresponds. A learner holding this credit would have standing for a computer course of ours, once there is one.
Recognition, both ways
The draft directive on standards and credits says that a learner who has completed a course of another institution that covers a course of the University may be given standing for it, and that the Chair of the faculty decides on the evidence. On this reading none of the four covers a course of ours, and none of ours covers one of them. The Indigenous Studies courses and ours are complementary. Another institution decides for itself what credit it grants.
What the comparison shows we lack
- A named teacher and a named Chair for every course, and the Chair’s and Dean’s approval. Every outline is still a draft.
- Someone to mark the written work of a learner who studies alone.
- Adoption of the draft directive by the Gazette. Every proposed rule is now a clause of it: what an outline must state, marks and their review, the use of AI, seminars, services, and changes to an outline.
- People to staff the services for learners: an adviser, a tutor, and a person to receive a disclosure.
- A course in computer applications: files, documents, spreadsheets, presentations and data.
- A course on health and care.
- The residential school system, with the Mohawk Institute. This waits until it is settled who should be part of writing it.
- The Sixties Scoop and child welfare, the events of 1990 and 1995, and the Royal Commission of 1996.
- Whether a creation account is taught, and by whom. That is for a knowledge keeper and the Chair.
Sources
- Cambrian College, course outline: IND1003 Intro to Indigenous Studies
- Cambrian College, course outline: IND1012 Truth and Reconciliation
- Cambrian College, course outline: IND1062 Indigenous Perspectives on Care
- Cambrian College, course outline: CMP1011 Computer Applications
- University of Waterloo
- University of Toronto
- McMaster University
- University of British Columbia
- The European credit system (ECTS)
- University of Nottingham
- University of Technology Sydney
- Diné College