Study · Programmes · A university programme
Where the University stands
A university programme
Not a degree yet. A first year of university study, yes: the courses for it are written, and it can be offered once teachers are named. This page measures the University’s courses against what a university programme has to be, looks at what others offer Mohawk learners, and sets out the road from a certificate to a degree.
The measure
A bachelor’s degree in Ontario is normally 90 to 120 credits, which is thirty to forty one-term courses of about 120 hours each. The University has 49 courses, and each is a module of 14 to 17 hours: 703 learner hours in all. Grouped into term courses, with weekly seminars and a final essay, they make nine one-term courses, 27 units of the 90.
A unit here is Ontario’s: a one-term course is 3 units. In the University’s own measure a unit is four University credits, at ten learner hours a credit.
Nine tests of a university programme
Read across: the test, the standard as others state it, where the University stands today, and its standing.
| Test | The standard | Ours today | Standing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Size | Ontario’s framework: a bachelor’s degree is normally 90 to 120 credits in six to eight semesters, and an honours degree normally 120. England’s: 120 credits a year at ten hours a credit, and 360 for honours. | Nine term courses: 27 units, about 1,080 learner hours once each has its seminars. By England’s measure, 108 of the 120 credits of a first year. | A first year, nearly |
| Level | Six kinds of expectation, from depth and breadth of knowledge to autonomy. An honours degree asks for “more conceptual sophistication, specialized knowledge and intellectual autonomy”. | Every outcome is mapped to the six. Of 190 outcomes, 137 ask a learner to understand, 31 to apply, and 22 to analyse or judge. | First-year level |
| Shape | A field of study with a required core, courses at an upper level, and breadth outside the field. Trent’s honours degree in Indigenous Studies is 20 credits, 9 of them in the field: a core of 4, 2 at fourth-year level, 3 more, and breadth across four categories. | A core for the first year. Nothing yet at an upper level, no placement and no final project. | In part |
| The language | Queen’s certificate is four courses of Mohawk, 12 units, taught at Tyendinaga. Six Nations Polytechnic grants a bachelor’s degree in Mohawk or Cayuga. Onkwawenna Kentyohkwa’s adult immersion is two school years, full time. | KAN 101 and KAN 102 prepare a learner. No course is yet taught by a speaker. | Not yet |
| Teachers | Ontario’s assessment board asks that those who teach hold a credential at least one level higher than the programme. For Indigenous courses it accepts instead demonstrated knowledge of the subject. | Nobody is named. The Faculty Certificate is ready for those who will teach. | Not yet |
| Marks and records | Percentage grades, a transcript, the review of a mark, and rules on integrity. | All are written as clauses of the draft directive. No marker is named and no transcript is issued. | Proposed |
| Admission | Ontario’s framework: a secondary school diploma with six Grade 12 courses at university or university-and-college level, and an average the institution sets. | Every course is open to anyone, with standing for prior learning. A rule for entry to a programme is not yet written. | Not yet |
| Review from outside | The World Indigenous Nations Higher Education Consortium accredits on a self-study, a visiting committee and a ruling, renewed in ten years. Ontario’s universities answer to a Quality Council at arm’s length from them and from government. | Each faculty is set beside outside benchmarks and the comparison is published. Nobody from outside has yet reviewed a course. | Not yet |
| Authority | Ontario’s Act reserves the granting of a degree, and the name university, to bodies its Legislature or its Minister authorises. | The University stands on the Nation’s own authority and grants certificates in its own name. See the four routes below. | For decision |
What others offer
Read across: who offers it, the programme, its size and shape, and on what authority it is granted. Each is given as its own pages state it.
| Who | The programme | Size and shape | On what authority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Six Nations Polytechnic | Bachelor of Arts in Ogwehoweh Languages: Mohawk or Cayuga | Approved by Ontario in December 2015, “a historic first for an Indigenous institute”. An honours degree was announced for the fall of 2022. | It holds the Minister’s consent, through the Postsecondary Education Quality Assessment Board. Approved as an institution by the Indigenous Advanced Education and Skills Council in 2020, for ten years. Accredited by the World Indigenous Nations Higher Education Consortium in 2017. |
| Six Nations Polytechnic | University Consortium Year 1 | Up to ten courses, 30 transferable units, among them Mohawk or Cayuga language and grammar. | Each of six partner universities grants its own credit. |
| FNTI, Tyendinaga | Its own certificates, diplomas and degrees, among them a Bachelor of Indigenous Social Work | Stand-alone credentials since 2020. | The Council’s review of February 2020 “formally grants FNTI with the authority to confer standalone Indigenous certificates, diplomas and degrees”. Accredited by the Consortium in 2009. |
| Queen’s University, with Tsi Tyónnheht Onkwawén:na | Certificate in Mohawk Language and Culture | 12 units: four courses, beginning and intermediate, taught at Tyendinaga. | Queen’s grants the certificate. The language centre at Tyendinaga is its partner. |
| Trent University | B.A. Honours in Indigenous Studies | 20 credits, 9 of them in the field: a core of 4, 2 at fourth-year level, 3 more, and breadth across four categories. | A public university of Ontario. |
| McMaster University | Honours B.A. in Indigenous Studies | Four years. Entry after first year with at least a C. Its courses run from Introduction to Indigenous Studies to The Indian Act: A Social Problem. | A public university of Ontario. |
| Onkwawenna Kentyohkwa, Ohsweken | Adult immersion in Kanien’kéha | Two school years, full time. By 2019, 25 of its graduates were teaching the language. | A community programme, founded in the 1990s. |
The University’s own ground is the four instruments, the law of the Tract, the Register and lineage, and the Nation’s diplomacy. What these programmes have and it lacks is the language taught toward fluency, study at an upper level, research, and work in the community.
What can be offered: a Certificate in Mohawk Studies
Thirty units: ten one-term courses, about 1,200 learner hours. That is the size of the first year of a bachelor’s degree in Ontario, and of a Certificate of Higher Education in England. The name is proposed.
| Part | Courses | Units |
|---|---|---|
| Core | MU 2100 Loyalist Mohawk History and Law; MU 2200 Records, Lineage and the Register; MU 2300 Settler Studies and the Constitution; MU 2400 Mohawk Language, Arts and Culture; MU 2500 Diplomacy and Strategy; MU 2600 Method and Evidence; MU 2700 Public Service, Accounts and the Press | 21 |
| Kanien’kéha, taught by a speaker | Two courses at the level of a first-year Language 1A and 1B, by arrangement with speakers or with an existing programme. A speaker shows it instead by speaking, as prior learning. | 6 |
| One elective | MU 2800 or MU 2900, on teaching; or a first-year course of a partner university, such as academic writing. | 3 |
The nine term courses are built from every course the University has. Read across: the term course, the courses it is built from, the hours those give now, and the hours once a term adds thirty-six seminar hours, the source work and a final essay or brief.
| Term course | Built from | Module hours now | With a term’s seminars |
|---|---|---|---|
| MU 2100 Loyalist Mohawk History and Law | HIS 101, HIS 201, LAW 101, MAP 101, LAW 201, LAW 301, REC 101 | 98 | About 120 |
| MU 2200 Records, Lineage and the Register | REG 101, REG 201, REG 301, LIN 101, CIV 101, DIP 201 | 86 | About 120 |
| MU 2300 Settler Studies and the Constitution | SET 101, LAW 202, MAP 201, CIV 201, ECO 101 | 73 | About 120 |
| MU 2400 Mohawk Language, Arts and Culture | KAN 101, KAN 102, ART 101, ART 102, HIS 301, PUB 101, DIP 202 | 102 | About 120 |
| MU 2500 Diplomacy and Strategy | DIP 101, DIP 102, DIP 201, STR 101, DIP 301 | 78 | About 120 |
| MU 2600 Method and Evidence | HIS 102, LAW 102, CIV 103, LIN 102, MAP 102 | 70 | About 120 |
| MU 2700 Public Service, Accounts and the Press | REG 202, REG 203, ECO 102, CIV 102, PUB 102 | 72 | About 120 |
| MU 2800 Teaching and Learning 1: Design, Assessment and Access | FAC 100, FAC 101, FAC 102, FAC 103, FAC 104 | 70 | About 120 |
| MU 2900 Teaching and Learning 2: Practice | FAC 105, FAC 106, FAC 107, FAC 108, FAC 109 | 70 | About 120 |
Before it can be offered
- A teacher named for each term course, and a marker for the written work.
- Thirty-six seminar hours a term for each term course, timetabled.
- Speakers to teach the two language courses, or an arrangement with a programme that already does.
- Percentage grades, and a transcript issued from the Register.
- The draft directive adopted by the Gazette, and the certificate established by it.
- One review of the programme by a person from outside the University.
From a certificate to a degree
Read across: the stage, its units in all, what it adds, and its standing.
| Stage | Units | What it adds | Standing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Certificate | 30 | A first year: the core, two language courses and one elective. | Written. It needs teachers and speakers. |
| Diploma | 60 | A second year: two more language courses, seven courses at an upper level, and one elective. | To be written. |
| A bachelor’s degree, by Ontario’s framework | 90 | A third year: two more language courses, seven upper-level courses, among them a placement and a final project, and one elective. | To be written. |
The second and third years need fourteen courses at an upper level, each a term long. They are proposed here from what the University’s own benchmarks say each faculty lacks. Read across: the field, the course, and the reason for it.
| Field | Course to be written | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Method | Research methods and research ethics, with a research essay | The history benchmark asks for a research essay as the faculty’s capstone. |
| History | The Mohawk and the Confederacy before 1784 | The survey that stands behind HIS 101. |
| History | The Grand River from 1784 to the present | The benchmark names the events of 1990 and 1995. The lesson on the Mohawk Institute belongs here, and waits on who is to be part of writing it. |
| Law | Treaties and the Crown | Upper-level study of what LAW 101 begins. |
| Law | Canada’s law of Aboriginal and treaty rights, as its courts state it, set beside the Nation’s position | LAW 201 names two roads. A learner should know the one the Nation does not take. |
| Law | International law and Indigenous peoples | Upper-level study of what DIP 301 begins. |
| Law | Private law: contract, property and wrongs | The law benchmark names it as not yet taught. |
| Government | Public administration: budgets, policy and the public service | The civics benchmark asks for public budgets and how a citizen reads one. |
| Economy | The Nation’s economy: trade, tax and enterprise | The economy benchmark asks for a second course. |
| Land | Land, water and the environment of the Grand River, with a field day | The maps benchmark asks for a field day with a surveyor. |
| Letters | Literature, oral tradition and broadcast | The publishing benchmark asks for writing and law for broadcast. |
| Arts | A studio course in one art, taught by a maker | The arts benchmark asks for it. |
| Community | A placement with an office of the Nation or a community body | Work done for others, and reported on. |
| Final project | A research project, written and defended | Original work, which the expectations for a degree ask for at its end. |
Two further courses have been raised and wait on a decision: computer applications, and health and care. Either could take an elective’s place.
Who must be in place
- A Dean, and a Chair for each faculty.
- Teachers named for every course, each with a credential above the level taught or with knowledge the community recognises.
- Speakers of Kanien’kéha to teach the language courses.
- An academic council, to approve programmes and hear appeals.
- A registrar’s office that issues a transcript from the Register.
- Reviewers from outside the University.
Four routes to recognition
- On the Nation’s own authority. The University grants its own certificate, entered in the Register under a Record Code. What any other body makes of it is that body’s decision. This is where the University stands today.
- By agreement with a university. A university grants the credential, and the community teaches or hosts it. Queen’s certificate is taught at Tyendinaga with the language centre there, and the Polytechnic’s first year carries six universities’ credit. Ontario’s Act allows a body to teach a degree programme under an agreement with an institution authorised to grant the degree, which then confers it. See the consortium pathway.
- By accreditation among Indigenous nations. The World Indigenous Nations Higher Education Consortium accredits Indigenous-serving institutions that give formal academic credentials. Its steps are a letter of intent, an eligibility application, a self-study, a visiting committee and a ruling, and accreditation is renewed in ten years. Six Nations Polytechnic and FNTI hold it. It is a judgement of quality by peers, and is not a licence from any government.
- By Ontario’s route for Indigenous Institutes. Ontario’s Indigenous Institutes Act, 2017 names nine institutes in regulation, and a Council reviews them. FNTI’s review of 2020 gave it authority to grant its own degrees. This route places an institution under an Ontario statute. The University has said that it is not constituted under Ontario law and does not seek to be.
The word degree. Ontario’s Post-secondary Education Choice and Excellence Act, 2000 says that nobody may grant a degree, teach a programme leading to one, or use the name university, without an Act of its Legislature or its Minister’s consent. The Nation’s position is that the University is its own and is not constituted under Ontario law. The two positions have not been reconciled, and this page does not try to reconcile them. Today the University grants certificates in its own name and calls nothing a degree. Whether it should grant a degree in its own name is a decision for the Secretary-General, on the Attorney General’s review.
What a learner can be told today
- The courses are written, free for registered members of the Nation, and each has an outline, outcomes, graded tasks and a rubric.
- The certificate is the University’s own, entered in the Register, and anyone can check it.
- No university or college has yet agreed to accept it for credit. Each decides for itself.
- It is not a degree, and the University does not call it one.
Sources
- Ontario, Ontario Qualifications Framework
- Quality Assurance Agency, Higher Education Credit Framework for England
- Ontario, Post-secondary Education Choice and Excellence Act, 2000
- Ontario, Indigenous Institutes
- Postsecondary Education Quality Assessment Board, terminal credentials
- World Indigenous Nations Higher Education Consortium, accredited institutions
- World Indigenous Nations Higher Education Consortium, Accreditation Handbook
- Six Nations Polytechnic, news release of 22 April 2022
- McMaster University, Six Nations Polytechnic BA blazes a trail
- FNTI, accreditation
- Queen’s University, Certificate in Mohawk Language and Culture
- Queen’s University, quality assurance processes
- Trent University, B.A. Honours in Indigenous Studies: requirements
- McMaster University, Honours Bachelor of Arts in Indigenous Studies
- Two Row Times, 22 May 2019, on Onkwawenna Kentyohkwa