Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Universities and colleges · MU 3100 Research Methods and Research Ethics · Examination

MU 3100 · a sample paper

The term examination

Two hours, one hundred marks, in three parts. This is a sample paper: the paper a learner sits is drawn afresh and is held by the Registrar of the University. It is sat in a room with an invigilator, or held aloud with the teacher. No software watches a learner.

The plan of the paper

Read across: the part, what it holds, its marks, and how it is set and marked.

PartWhat it holdsMarksHow it is set and marked
AThirty questions, one mark each30Drawn from the bank of all the term’s courses, six from each. Marked at once.
BA source, and three short answers40Question 1, on a source printed in the paper, is compulsory. Then three of five short answers. Ten marks each.
COne essay30One of three questions. Marked for its argument, its evidence, the objection it meets, and its writing.

The bank for this term holds 162 questions: 60 test recall, 54 application and 48 analysis.

Part A · thirty marks

Thirty questions. In the paper a learner sits they are drawn afresh; these are the sample paper’s own. No answers are published.

  1. Choose oneYour table shows six works that all rest on officials’ papers, and none on what families hold. What have you found?
    1. Proof that the officials were right
    2. A gap
    3. Nothing of use
    4. An error in the table
  2. Choose oneA proposal asks leave to copy the words of a ceremony from the Nation’s records. What happens to it?
    1. It is given a longer timetable
    2. It is passed to a funder
    3. It is approved if the question is good
    4. It is refused: nothing sacred or restricted is taught or reproduced
  3. Choose oneA learner writes: “I will show that the Patent of 1793 was unlawful.” What is wrong with this as a research question?
    1. Nothing is wrong with it
    2. It is too narrow
    3. It names a date
    4. It states the answer before the work begins
  4. Choose oneA study asks whether people trusted the land office, and counts how many deeds were registered there. What is its weakness?
    1. Deeds cannot be counted
    2. Registering a deed may not show trust: the evidence bears on something near the question
    3. The count is too large
    4. It has no weakness
  5. Choose oneWhat does it mean to design against yourself?
    1. To change the question later
    2. To choose a weak method
    3. To look where you would find evidence that you are wrong
  6. Choose oneOn what is a proposal judged?
    1. Its length
    2. Whether this method can answer this question, in this time, without harm
    3. How many sources it lists
  7. Choose oneAn Elder who taught you asks not to be named. What is right?
    1. Name a relative in their place
    2. Credit them in the way they choose, which may be not at all
    3. Leave out what they taught
    4. Name them anyway, for accuracy
  8. Choose oneA report on a village of forty households describes “the man who kept the store” and gives no name. Is he protected?
    1. Only while he is living
    2. Yes, if the report is short
    3. Yes: no name was printed
    4. No: other details show who he is
  9. From the sourceWhich words make it a breach to leave out contrary evidence?
    1. such that the research record is not accurately represented.
    2. Making up data, source material, methodologies or findings,
    3. without appropriate acknowledgement,
    4. Manipulating, changing, or omitting data,
  10. Choose oneA person agrees aloud, and the researcher writes down that they did. Under the policy, is that consent?
    1. Only outside a community
    2. Only for a child
    3. No: only a signature counts
    4. Yes: consent need not be a signed form
  11. Choose oneWhy is one member’s consent not enough for a people’s knowledge?
    1. Members cannot consent to anything
    2. It is always secret
    3. It is held in common
  12. Choose oneIs leaving out contrary evidence a breach?
    1. Only in science
    2. Yes; omitting data so that the record misleads is falsification
    3. No, if what is printed is true
  13. From the sourceWhich words let a person take back what they have already said?
    1. the participant can also request the withdrawal of their data
    2. Consent shall be given voluntarily.
    3. Consent can be withdrawn at any time.
  14. Choose oneYou study the meetings of your own community. What should your account include?
    1. A short statement of who you are in relation to it
    2. Nothing about yourself
    3. An apology
    4. Your qualifications alone
  15. From the sourceWhich words of the Pledge name the people to whom it was given?
    1. Some of the Mohawks of the Villages of Canojaharie, Tikondarago, and Aughugo,
    2. as soon as that happy time comes.
    3. the same should be restored at the expense of the Government,
    4. my predecessor, Sir Guy Carleton, was pleased to promise,
  16. Choose oneNine of ten speakers support your theme and one contradicts it. What do you do with her account?
    1. Leave it out
    2. Count it with the nine
    3. Interview her again until she agrees
    4. Report it, and say what it shows
  17. Choose oneHow are archives arranged?
    1. By colour
    2. By subject
    3. By who made the records
  18. Choose oneWhat is member checking?
    1. Checking a membership card
    2. Counting the members of a group
    3. Taking findings back to the people before they are final
  19. Choose oneA report says a programme cut absences, because absences fell after it began. What is the first question to ask?
    1. Who wrote the report?
    2. Was it well liked?
    3. Compared with what: what happened where there was no programme?
    4. What did it cost?
  20. From the sourceWhich words state the comparison on which Snow’s finding rests?
    1. the handle of the pump was removed on the following day.
    2. except among the persons who were in the habit of drinking the water of the above-mentioned pump-well.
    3. there had been no particular outbreak or increase of cholera, in this part of London,
    4. I had an interview with the Board of Guardians of St. James’s parish,
  21. Choose oneIn the same case, from 20 per cent to 26 per cent, by what proportion of itself has the share grown?
    1. 26 per cent
    2. 6 per cent
    3. 30 per cent
    4. 46 per cent
  22. Choose oneA nation of three hundred wishes to know how many of its households heat with wood. What is the best design?
    1. A poll open to anyone online
    2. Ask the first twenty at a meeting
    3. Ask every household
    4. A random sample of thirty
  23. Choose oneWhy can two honest counts of the same people differ?
    1. Counting is guesswork
    2. One of them must be false
    3. They define who is counted differently
  24. Choose oneDoes a larger sample cure a badly chosen one?
    1. Only above a million
    2. Yes, always
    3. No; two million answers from the wrong people still mislead
  25. Choose oneA learner changes four words of a historian’s sentence and gives no reference. What is this?
    1. A paraphrase
    2. Common knowledge
    3. A quotation
    4. Plagiarism
  26. From the sourceWhich words tell a writer to put the contrary evidence in the essay herself?
    1. Say what a source holds — no more:
    2. a case is cited for what it decided;
    3. where an authority cuts against the Nation, the book says so before a critic does.
    4. the Nation’s inference from it is called the Nation’s inference.
  27. From the sourceWhich words show that an idea must be cited, and not only a sentence?
    1. including theories, concepts, data, source material, methodologies, findings, graphs and images.
    2. for the use of all published and unpublished work,
    3. Referencing and, where applicable, obtaining permission
  28. Choose oneWhich entry cites an Elder as the forms published in 2021 set out?
    1. “Personal communication”, with nothing in the list of sources
    2. No mention at all
    3. A first name only
    4. The name, the nation or community, where they live, the subject taught, and the date
  29. Choose oneWhat should a writer do while a draft is reviewed?
    1. Listen and write it down
    2. Leave the room
    3. Defend each point at once
  30. Choose oneWhat is a warrant?
    1. A footnote
    2. The reason the evidence supports the claim
    3. A court order

Part B · forty marks

Question 1 is compulsory. Read the source, then answer.

The source

The result of the inquiry then was, that there had been no particular outbreak or increase of cholera, in this part of London, except among the persons who were in the habit of drinking the water of the above-mentioned pump-well. I had an interview with the Board of Guardians of St. James’s parish, on the evening of Thursday, 7th September, and represented the above circumstances to them. In consequence of what I said, the handle of the pump was removed on the following day.
John Snow, On the Mode of Communication of Cholera (1855): the Broad Street pump · Second edition (London: John Churchill, 1855).

1. What comparison does Snow’s finding rest on? Name two other explanations he had to rule out. Why is the removal of the handle, by itself, weak evidence that the pump was the cause? (10 marks)

Then answer three of these five. Ten marks each.

  1. Take the topic “the copying of the Proclamation of 1784”. Write a research question on it, and show that it passes the four tests.
  2. State the three marks of consent, and give one case in which each is missing.
  3. A university offers to keep the recordings of interviews with the Nation’s members on its own servers, and to open them to other researchers. Advise the Nation, using the four principles.
  4. Seven households have 1, 2, 2, 3, 3, 4 and 13 people. Give the mean, the median and the range. Which measure of the centre would you report, and why?
  5. Explain how an Elder’s teaching is cited, and why it is not cited as a “personal communication”.

Part C · thirty marks

Answer one.

  1. A Māori scholar has written that research is among the dirtiest words in the Indigenous world’s vocabulary. Explain why that has been said, and set out what a researcher must do so that it need not be true of their own work.
  2. Who owns what a study of a people gathers? Discuss, setting the four principles beside the practice of universities and journals.
  3. A finding that rests on a document, a witness and a measurement is harder to shake than one that rests on any one of them. Discuss, with an example of each kind of evidence and its weakness.

Parts B and C are written by hand or spoken, and marked by the teacher to the marking guide, which is given to the examiner. One paper in five is marked again by a second marker.